latimes--2020-12-21--L.A. County allows churches to meet indoors after recent court rulings

Los Angeles County officials have lifted a ban on indoor religious services after a series of court rulings involving houses of worship that argued that the pandemic-related restrictions violate religious freedoms .
While county churches are again permitted to hold indoor services under the new policy , announced Saturday , they must still comply with other restrictions , such as social distancing and mask wearing .
The loosened public health guidelines come amid surging coronavirus infection rates and hospitalizations and as some churches continue to defy public health orders .
County officials , who had issued the order blocking indoor @ @ @ @ @ @ @ to urge houses of worship not to meet indoors because it will increase congregants ’ chances of contracting the coronavirus .
The vast majority of churches have complied , but some have not .
“ Los Angeles County is experiencing an unprecedented surge of COVID-19 cases , hospitalizations and premature deaths , ” county officials said in a statement .
“ The county ’ s hospitals and ICUs are full and must care for approximately 200 new COVID-19 patients a day .
The current status of healthcare capacity in the county is dire.
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ of rulings by courts across the country , including the U.S. Supreme Court .
All involve faith organizations claiming that public health orders infringe on their constitutionally protected right of freedom of religion .
The Supreme Court in late November , in a pair of 5-4 orders , ruled in a case about New York ’ s restrictions on houses of worship that states could not place more stringent checks on religious organizations than they do on businesses and other places where large gatherings occur .
This month , a Kern County judge @ @ @ @ @ @ @ declared that restrictions on religious services in California are unconstitutional .
He barred the state , L.A. County and several other counties and cities from enforcing any prohibition on indoor religious services .
L.A. County officials insist that the public health orders are appropriate .
They are intended to keep people home and among their households as much as possible but will not work “ unless individual residents and businesses take personal responsibility to implement these very necessary infection-control precautions in their daily routines , ” the county statement said .
Although houses @ @ @ @ @ @ @ and attendees must follow measures to protect themselves and the public .
Under the county ’ s public health order , staff and visitors must wear face coverings at all times and maintain a distance of at least six feet from anyone outside their households .
Houses of worship must conduct screenings before visitors enter and disinfect worship spaces between services .
Singing is allowed but “ strongly discouraged , ” public health officials said , noting that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends the suspension of singing , chanting and @ @ @ @ @ @ @ from a common cup or eating from the same piece of bread is not allowed under the county ’ s order .
Communion must be conducted outdoors , with congregants staying six feet apart and immediately replacing their face coverings afterward , health officials said .
“ This protocol does not obligate places of worship to resume any in-person activity , ” county public health officials said in the guidance released Saturday .
“ Further , it is strongly recommended that places of worship continue to facilitate outdoor or remote services and other @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Southern California , conservative Christian churches have been among the most defiant of county and state public health orders .
In San Bernardino County , Calvary Chapel Chino Hills has continued to hold indoor worship services despite the prohibition .
Ventura County officials in August sued Godspeak Calvary Chapel in Thousand Oaks after it continued to meet indoors .
“ Singing , hugging , no masks , ” Senior Pastor Rob McCoy said , describing the services .
That open defiance has led to lawsuits in L.A. County as well .
In August @ @ @ @ @ @ @ in Sun Valley for its open defiance of the public health order .
Since July , the church has held services attended by thousands , many of whom do not wear masks or maintain distance from other attendees .
Despite a judge ’ s order not to meet indoors , the church continued to do .
A contempt hearing is scheduled for Jan. 15 .
Sun Valley , a primarily Latino neighborhood , has among the highest coronavirus case rates in the county , according to data from the health department .
The @ @ @ @ @ @ @ increased tenfold since the beginning of October .
Pastors at Grace Community Church did not respond Monday to emails or messages on social media requesting comment .
Pastor John MacArthur has openly repudiated COVID-19 guidance , declaring in an August sermon that “ there is no pandemic.
” MacArthur has repeatedly compared the coronavirus to influenza and has parroted conspiracy theories pushed by conservative news websites .
Times staff writers Maura Dolan and David Savage and research librarian Scott Wilson contributed to this report .

Los Angeles County officials have lifted a ban on indoor religious services after a series of court rulings involving houses of worship that argued that the pandemic-related restrictions violate religious freedoms.
While county churches are again permitted to hold indoor services under the new policy, announced Saturday, they must still comply with other restrictions, such as social distancing and mask wearing.
The loosened public health guidelines come amid surging coronavirus infection rates and hospitalizations and as some churches continue to defy public health orders.
County officials, who had issued the order blocking indoor services early in the pandemic, continue to urge houses of worship not to meet indoors because it will increase congregants’ chances of contracting the coronavirus. The vast majority of churches have complied, but some have not.
“Los Angeles County is experiencing an unprecedented surge of COVID-19 cases, hospitalizations and premature deaths,” county officials said in a statement. “The county’s hospitals and ICUs are full and must care for approximately 200 new COVID-19 patients a day. The current status of healthcare capacity in the county is dire.”
Advertisement
The reversal comes after a series of rulings by courts across the country, including the U.S. Supreme Court. All involve faith organizations claiming that public health orders infringe on their constitutionally protected right of freedom of religion.
The Supreme Court in late November, in a pair of 5-4 orders, ruled in a case about New York’s restrictions on houses of worship that states could not place more stringent checks on religious organizations than they do on businesses and other places where large gatherings occur.
This month, a Kern County judge, citing the Supreme Court decision, declared that restrictions on religious services in California are unconstitutional. He barred the state, L.A. County and several other counties and cities from enforcing any prohibition on indoor religious services.
L.A. County officials insist that the public health orders are appropriate. They are intended to keep people home and among their households as much as possible but will not work “unless individual residents and businesses take personal responsibility to implement these very necessary infection-control precautions in their daily routines,” the county statement said.
Although houses of worship can meet indoors, staff and attendees must follow measures to protect themselves and the public. Under the county’s public health order, staff and visitors must wear face coverings at all times and maintain a distance of at least six feet from anyone outside their households. Houses of worship must conduct screenings before visitors enter and disinfect worship spaces between services.
Singing is allowed but “strongly discouraged,” public health officials said, noting that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends the suspension of singing, chanting and shouting, especially when indoors.
Drinking from a common cup or eating from the same piece of bread is not allowed under the county’s order. Communion must be conducted outdoors, with congregants staying six feet apart and immediately replacing their face coverings afterward, health officials said.
Advertisement
“This protocol does not obligate places of worship to resume any in-person activity,” county public health officials said in the guidance released Saturday. “Further, it is strongly recommended that places of worship continue to facilitate outdoor or remote services and other related activities for all attendees.”
Across Southern California, conservative Christian churches have been among the most defiant of county and state public health orders.
In San Bernardino County, Calvary Chapel Chino Hills has continued to hold indoor worship services despite the prohibition. Ventura County officials in August sued Godspeak Calvary Chapel in Thousand Oaks after it continued to meet indoors.
“Singing, hugging, no masks,” Senior Pastor Rob McCoy said, describing the services.
That open defiance has led to lawsuits in L.A. County as well. In August, the county sued Grace Community Church in Sun Valley for its open defiance of the public health order. Since July, the church has held services attended by thousands, many of whom do not wear masks or maintain distance from other attendees. Despite a judge’s order not to meet indoors, the church continued to do. A contempt hearing is scheduled for Jan. 15.
Sun Valley, a primarily Latino neighborhood, has among the highest coronavirus case rates in the county, according to data from the health department. The case rate among Sun Valley residents has increased tenfold since the beginning of October.
Pastors at Grace Community Church did not respond Monday to emails or messages on social media requesting comment.
Pastor John MacArthur has openly repudiated COVID-19 guidance, declaring in an August sermon that “there is no pandemic.” MacArthur has repeatedly compared the coronavirus to influenza and has parroted conspiracy theories pushed by conservative news websites.
Times staff writers Maura Dolan and David Savage and research librarian Scott Wilson contributed to this report.


latimes--2020-12-21--Investigation launched as Inyo County voters say they didn't sign tobacco referendum

Elections officials in Inyo County said Monday that at least 70 % of the signatures submitted to block a California law banning the sale of flavored tobacco are invalid , with dozens of voters saying they never signed the petition .
Kammie Foote , the county ’ s registrar of voters , said she has submitted the findings of her staff ’ s investigation to the Inyo County district attorney ’ s office .
She said that in some cases , the signatures were not even close to matching those on file with her office .
In one case , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ official appeared on a petition and looked distinctly different from the signature that appears on a variety of government documents .
“ We ’ re confident that these are not valid signatures , ” Foote said .
Whether the problems reported in Inyo County , a rural community with about 11,000 registered voters , are an anomaly is unclear .
State elections officials said Monday this is the first such report regarding the effort to qualify a ballot measure to block the tobacco law signed in August by Gov .
Gavin Newsom .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ petition and submitting the document to elections officials are misdemeanors under state law , punishable by jail time and a fine of up to $ 5,000 .
Last month , a campaign funded by the nation ’ s largest tobacco companies announced it had gathered more than 1 million voter signatures to qualify a referendum on the new law for the November 2022 statewide election .
The law , Senate Bill 793 , outlaws the retail sale of flavored tobacco products in California and is scheduled to take effect on Jan. 1 .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ 623,212 valid voter signatures have been gathered , the enactment of SB 793 will be on hold for at least the next two years .
Under California law , voters can overturn a statute signed by the governor through a referendum — having done so most recently last month , when they rejected Proposition 25 and the plan to eliminate cash bail in the state .
Foote said the inquiry began when her staff started to spot-check the signatures turned in by the professional circulators hired through the tobacco industry-funded campaign .
To @ @ @ @ @ @ @ not honored , her office routinely makes phone calls to see whether a person signed the petition .
“ Voter after voter said , ‘ I did not sign this petition ’ , ” Foote said .
Of the 268 signatures submitted to Inyo officials , 186 were deemed to not match the voter ’ s signature on file .
Two of the voters had died .
That would leave no more than 80 of the signatures to be valid .
Foote said it ’ s possible the paid petition gatherers were using @ @ @ @ @ @ @ some of the rejected signatures included old home addresses of the voters .
The campaign in support of the tobacco referendum didn ’ t immediately respond to a request seeking comment .

California lawmakers banned the sale of flavored tobacco products, including those used in electronic cigarettes, and the tobacco industry is seeking to overturn the statute through a ballot referendum in 2022.
Elections officials in Inyo County said Monday that at least 70% of the signatures submitted to block a California law banning the sale of flavored tobacco are invalid, with dozens of voters saying they never signed the petition.
Kammie Foote, the county’s registrar of voters, said she has submitted the findings of her staff’s investigation to the Inyo County district attorney’s office. She said that in some cases, the signatures were not even close to matching those on file with her office. In one case, the name of a prominent local elected official appeared on a petition and looked distinctly different from the signature that appears on a variety of government documents.
“We’re confident that these are not valid signatures,” Foote said.
Whether the problems reported in Inyo County, a rural community with about 11,000 registered voters, are an anomaly is unclear. State elections officials said Monday this is the first such report regarding the effort to qualify a ballot measure to block the tobacco law signed in August by Gov. Gavin Newsom.
Advertisement
Forging a signature on a ballot measure petition and submitting the document to elections officials are misdemeanors under state law, punishable by jail time and a fine of up to $5,000.
Last month, a campaign funded by the nation’s largest tobacco companies announced it had gathered more than 1 million voter signatures to qualify a referendum on the new law for the November 2022 statewide election. The law, Senate Bill 793, outlaws the retail sale of flavored tobacco products in California and is scheduled to take effect on Jan. 1.
But if elections officials determine at least 623,212 valid voter signatures have been gathered, the enactment of SB 793 will be on hold for at least the next two years. Under California law, voters can overturn a statute signed by the governor through a referendum — having done so most recently last month, when they rejected Proposition 25 and the plan to eliminate cash bail in the state.
Foote said the inquiry began when her staff started to spot-check the signatures turned in by the professional circulators hired through the tobacco industry-funded campaign. To ensure no voter’s intent is not honored, her office routinely makes phone calls to see whether a person signed the petition.
“Voter after voter said, ‘I did not sign this petition’,” Foote said.
Of the 268 signatures submitted to Inyo officials, 186 were deemed to not match the voter’s signature on file. Two of the voters had died. That would leave no more than 80 of the signatures to be valid. Foote said it’s possible the paid petition gatherers were using an outdated voter registration list, as some of the rejected signatures included old home addresses of the voters.
The campaign in support of the tobacco referendum didn’t immediately respond to a request seeking comment.


latimes--2020-12-23--COVID-19 outbreaks surge at L.A. County malls as holiday shoppers pour in

Paola Hernández watched as shoppers at the Citadel Outlets bumped shoulders and ignored signs directing foot traffic under bow-adorned palm trees .
Two girls stood a few feet behind her licking ice cream cones , even though eating has been banned in malls .
Hernandez , 57 , and her daughter went to the outdoor mall in Commerce on Monday when they weren ’ t able to find the holiday presents they wanted to buy online , she said .
But even sitting on a bench outside had started to feel unsafe when , despite a sign stating it seated @ @ @ @ @ @ @ down next to her .
“ I do feel scared .
... A lot of us don ’ t follow the rules .
That ’ s the problem , ” said Hernandez , who lives in El Monte .
“ The virus is in the air.
” In this latest , most dire phase of the pandemic , as millions of Californians have been asked to stay home and avoid their families for the holidays , packed shopping malls have become a flashpoint .
In recent weeks , Los Angeles County officials have @ @ @ @ @ @ @ and shuttered nail and hair salons .
Yet , as case numbers continue to rise unabated and hospitals warn they may soon be forced to ration care , malls have continued to welcome holiday shoppers .
Shopping malls and retail businesses deemed nonessential must limit occupancy to 20 % of their maximum capacity , under county rules .
But in the eyes of many , even public officials , they remain unsafe .
L.A. County health services director Dr. Christina Ghaly said that recent images of busy shopping centers worried her .
On @ @ @ @ @ @ @ outrage online after showing cars vying for parking spots at the Citadel .
“ If you ’ re still out there shopping for your loved ones for this holiday season ... then you are missing the gravity of the situation that is affecting hospitals across L.A. County , ” Ghaly said Monday .
“ Though they may seem benign , these actions are extremely high-risk.
” Indeed , as COVID spreads faster than ever in L.A. County , it has reached malls , too .
The vast majority of outbreaks reported at shopping @ @ @ @ @ @ @ the past four weeks , according to a Times analysis of data posted on An outbreak is defined as three or more cases among staff in a 14-day period .
At the Northridge Fashion Center , 12 J.C. Penney employees recently tested positive for the coronavirus , as did 10 at Kohl ’ s in the South Bay Galleria in Redondo Beach and 24 at the Best Buy in the West Hollywood Gateway retail center , which prompted a six-day closure of the store .
New outbreaks have also been reported at Vans @ @ @ @ @ @ @ at the Glendale Galleria and Forever 21 at the Montebello Town Center .
The cases don ’ t necessarily reflect unsafe practices on the part of companies as much as the difficulty of controlling spread when prevalence of the virus is this high , experts say .
Outbreaks are soaring across industries , with 505 businesses in L.A. County in the midst of one as of Tuesday , compared with 204 a month ago , according to county data .
To many , the flare-ups at retail stores and shopping malls exemplify the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ : Stores that sell nonessential goods , such as books , jeans and TVs , remain open for in-store browsing , while officials warn that it is dangerous to leave the house unless absolutely necessary .
“ It ’ s like telling little kids ‘ You can ’ t have a lollipop , but I ’ m going to put one right there in front of you , ” said Reina Morataya , a manager at a clothing store at Plaza El Segundo , where customers have been flooding in recent days .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ — compelled by a lack of federal relief to help ailing businesses — has muddied the public health message , said UCLA epidemiology professor Shira Shafir .
“ There ’ s been so much messaging in the pandemic that said , ‘ It ’ s not safe for X to be open , so we ’ re going to close X , ’ ” she said .
“ It ’ s totally reasonable for people to then interpret the inverse : ‘ If it ’ s open , it must be safe.
’ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ County careens toward catastrophe , public health director Barbara Ferrer said Monday she was not considering further closures , noting that retail is already at a “ much-reduced ” 20 % capacity .
At the Citadel Outlets on Monday , a line snaked outside the Calvin Klein store , where an outbreak infected three staff members earlier this month .
Inside the mostly empty store , shoppers had plenty of room to space out and employees in masks frequently approached the hand sanitizer dispenser .
But the rest of the outdoor mall was @ @ @ @ @ @ @ one another in their rush to their next destination , forming looping queues as they waited to get into stores .
At an outdoor kiosk selling anime figurines , an employee sprayed her hands with sanitizer .
She pointed to shoppers walking by , disobeying the one-way signs , and said she worries when customers get too close .
“ But what to do ?
We have to pay the rent , ” she said .
Shopping malls and retail stores were closed in the early months of the pandemic , as widespread @ @ @ @ @ @ @ In-store shopping was restarted in early May , and indoor malls followed in October as COVID-19 spread in L.A. County hit a low point .
But when more people began to fall sick the following month , officials tried to curb the spread while also closing as few stores as possible , as federal relief for businesses had dried up .
So while taking a masked walk with a friend was banned under the new orders , retail shops remained open at 20 % capacity .
As comedian Johan Miranda , “ Just @ @ @ @ @ @ @ at home orders I can ’ t see her unless we happen to be shopping at the same Target.
” The decisions to keep these stores open have not been without health consequences .
Workplaces are an ideal setting for the spread of COVID-19 — indoor environments where people interact in close quarters for hours on end .
Even a classic Southern California outdoor mall does not help much , since the workers spend all day inside the stores .
Outbreaks have been reported this month at the Apple Store at the Beverly @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Center as well as Amazon Books and Nordstrom at the Los Cerritos Center .
Half of the outbreaks reported at Target stores in L.A. County during the pandemic were reported in December .
Five Costco branches have been hit with outbreaks in the past two weeks , and at least 135 staff have been infected , according to county records .
Representatives from impacted companies told The Times they have followed all protocols and that cases often originate outside the workplace .
Apple opted on Saturday to close all its California stores “ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ we closely monitor the situation , ” a spokesperson said .
Rachel Michelin , president of the California Retailers Assn.
, said the organization has asked the state for information that would help determine whether infections are coming from shopping centers , but the requests have gone unanswered .
Without that clarity , retailers are moving forward with their best efforts to keep shoppers and employees safe , she said .
“ We ’ ve openly said if retail is a major problem in transmission of COVID-19 , show us the data , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ ’ t just blame businesses for behavior of people who are going out and having parties or going to other households.
” L.A. County chief medical officer Dr. Jeffrey Gunzenhauser said the high number of workplace outbreaks is mostly a reflection of how widespread the coronavirus is in the county — currently 1 in 80 residents are believed to be infectious .
Contact tracing interviews from the first half of December found that among people who contracted COVID-19 and were employed , 8 % worked in retail , he said .
“ When @ @ @ @ @ @ @ more outbreaks in facilities , they think there ’ s a lot of transmission going on there , and that isn ’ t necessarily true , ” he said .
“ It ’ s just because there are so many cases.
” Since late August , county investigators have fined businesses up to $ 500 each time they seriously violate COVID safety precautions .
The Citadel has been fined four times since November , according to county records .
In response , the mall “ took the feedback from health officials seriously ” @ @ @ @ @ @ @ eat or drink , made walkways wider , ensured proper spacing in lines , canceled all live events and expanded curbside pickup options , said Citadel general manager David Blagg .
“ We ’ re pleased to share that we received another visit from Los Angeles County Department of Public Health yesterday and were found compliant , ” he wrote in an email Tuesday .

Soumya Karlamangla, Alejandra Reyes-Velarde

People walk against the suggested flow of foot traffic for coronavirus precautions at the Citadel Outlets in Commerce on Tuesday.
Paola Hernández watched as shoppers at the Citadel Outlets bumped shoulders and ignored signs directing foot traffic under bow-adorned palm trees. Two girls stood a few feet behind her licking ice cream cones, even though eating has been banned in malls.
Hernandez, 57, and her daughter went to the outdoor mall in Commerce on Monday when they weren’t able to find the holiday presents they wanted to buy online, she said. But even sitting on a bench outside had started to feel unsafe when, despite a sign stating it seated only two, a third person sat down next to her.
“I do feel scared. ... A lot of us don’t follow the rules. That’s the problem,” said Hernandez, who lives in El Monte. “The virus is in the air.”
Advertisement
In this latest, most dire phase of the pandemic, as millions of Californians have been asked to stay home and avoid their families for the holidays, packed shopping malls have become a flashpoint.
In recent weeks, Los Angeles County officials have banned outdoor dining, temporarily closed playgrounds and shuttered nail and hair salons. Yet, as case numbers continue to rise unabated and hospitals warn they may soon be forced to ration care, malls have continued to welcome holiday shoppers.
Shopping malls and retail businesses deemed nonessential must limit occupancy to 20% of their maximum capacity, under county rules. But in the eyes of many, even public officials, they remain unsafe.
L.A. County health services director Dr. Christina Ghaly said that recent images of busy shopping centers worried her. On Saturday, an NBC News video sparked outrage online after showing cars vying for parking spots at the Citadel.
“If you’re still out there shopping for your loved ones for this holiday season ... then you are missing the gravity of the situation that is affecting hospitals across L.A. County,” Ghaly said Monday. “Though they may seem benign, these actions are extremely high-risk.”
Advertisement
California Coronavirus wave pushes California to brink of 2 million cases The numbers show the coronavirus circulating statewide; behaviors thought to be relatively safe weeks ago now carry a higher risk of infection.
Indeed, as COVID spreads faster than ever in L.A. County, it has reached malls, too. The vast majority of outbreaks reported at shopping malls during the pandemic were reported in the past four weeks, according to a Times analysis of data posted on the county’s website. An outbreak is defined as three or more cases among staff in a 14-day period.
At the Northridge Fashion Center, 12 J.C. Penney employees recently tested positive for the coronavirus, as did 10 at Kohl’s in the South Bay Galleria in Redondo Beach and 24 at the Best Buy in the West Hollywood Gateway retail center, which prompted a six-day closure of the store.
New outbreaks have also been reported at Vans in the Burbank Town Center, Zara at the Glendale Galleria and Forever 21 at the Montebello Town Center.
The cases don’t necessarily reflect unsafe practices on the part of companies as much as the difficulty of controlling spread when prevalence of the virus is this high, experts say.
Outbreaks are soaring across industries, with 505 businesses in L.A. County in the midst of one as of Tuesday, compared with 204 a month ago, according to county data.
To many, the flare-ups at retail stores and shopping malls exemplify the contradiction of L.A.’s current COVID rules: Stores that sell nonessential goods, such as books, jeans and TVs, remain open for in-store browsing, while officials warn that it is dangerous to leave the house unless absolutely necessary.
“It’s like telling little kids, ‘You can’t have a lollipop, but I’m going to put one right there in front of you,’” said Reina Morataya, a manager at a clothing store at Plaza El Segundo, where customers have been flooding in recent days.
The economic decision to keep stores open — compelled by a lack of federal relief to help ailing businesses — has muddied the public health message, said UCLA epidemiology professor Shira Shafir.
“There’s been so much messaging in the pandemic that said, ‘It’s not safe for X to be open, so we’re going to close X,’” she said. “It’s totally reasonable for people to then interpret the inverse: ‘If it’s open, it must be safe.’”
Even as the situation in L.A. County careens toward catastrophe, public health director Barbara Ferrer said Monday she was not considering further closures, noting that retail is already at a “much-reduced” 20% capacity.
“Stay home,” she said.
At the Citadel Outlets on Monday, a line snaked outside the Calvin Klein store, where an outbreak infected three staff members earlier this month. Inside the mostly empty store, shoppers had plenty of room to space out and employees in masks frequently approached the hand sanitizer dispenser.
But the rest of the outdoor mall was a free-for-all, where customers brushed past one another in their rush to their next destination, forming looping queues as they waited to get into stores.
At an outdoor kiosk selling anime figurines, an employee sprayed her hands with sanitizer. She pointed to shoppers walking by, disobeying the one-way signs, and said she worries when customers get too close.
“But what to do? We have to pay the rent,” she said.
Shopping malls and retail stores were closed in the early months of the pandemic, as widespread shutdowns prohibited almost all indoor activities. In-store shopping was restarted in early May, and indoor malls followed in October as COVID-19 spread in L.A. County hit a low point.
California A family wonders if they should hope a loved one with COVID-19 lives or help him die Bob Harris told his family he didn’t want to be on a ventilator, but when his family wasn’t ready for him to stop fighting COVID-19, he agreed to be intubated. One week on the ventilator turned into three, and the Harris family faced a terrible decision.
But when more people began to fall sick the following month, officials tried to curb the spread while also closing as few stores as possible, as federal relief for businesses had dried up.
So while taking a masked walk with a friend was banned under the new orders, retail shops remained open at 20% capacity.
As comedian Johan Miranda tweeted , “Just told my mom under Los Angeles stay at home orders I can’t see her unless we happen to be shopping at the same Target.”
The decisions to keep these stores open have not been without health consequences.
Workplaces are an ideal setting for the spread of COVID-19 — indoor environments where people interact in close quarters for hours on end. Even a classic Southern California outdoor mall does not help much, since the workers spend all day inside the stores.
Outbreaks have been reported this month at the Apple Store at the Beverly Center, Michaels in the Burbank Empire Center as well as Amazon Books and Nordstrom at the Los Cerritos Center.
Half of the outbreaks reported at Target stores in L.A. County during the pandemic were reported in December. Five Costco branches have been hit with outbreaks in the past two weeks, and at least 135 staff have been infected, according to county records.
Representatives from impacted companies told The Times they have followed all protocols and that cases often originate outside the workplace. Apple opted on Saturday to close all its California stores “out of an abundance of caution as we closely monitor the situation,” a spokesperson said.
Rachel Michelin, president of the California Retailers Assn., said the organization has asked the state for information that would help determine whether infections are coming from shopping centers, but the requests have gone unanswered.
Without that clarity, retailers are moving forward with their best efforts to keep shoppers and employees safe, she said.
“We’ve openly said if retail is a major problem in transmission of COVID-19, show us the data,” Michelin said. “We can’t just blame businesses for behavior of people who are going out and having parties or going to other households.”
L.A. County chief medical officer Dr. Jeffrey Gunzenhauser said the high number of workplace outbreaks is mostly a reflection of how widespread the coronavirus is in the county — currently 1 in 80 residents are believed to be infectious.
Contact tracing interviews from the first half of December found that among people who contracted COVID-19 and were employed, 8% worked in retail, he said.
“When people hear there’s a lot more outbreaks in facilities, they think there’s a lot of transmission going on there, and that isn’t necessarily true,” he said. “It’s just because there are so many cases.”
Since late August, county investigators have fined businesses up to $500 each time they seriously violate COVID safety precautions.
The Citadel has been fined four times since November, according to county records. In response, the mall “took the feedback from health officials seriously” and improved signage telling people not to eat or drink, made walkways wider, ensured proper spacing in lines, canceled all live events and expanded curbside pickup options, said Citadel general manager David Blagg.
“We’re pleased to share that we received another visit from Los Angeles County Department of Public Health yesterday and were found compliant,” he wrote in an email Tuesday.


latimes--2020-12-23--'We called it Voyage of the Damned': Days of despair on the Grand Princess

Michael Dorety was a retired 68-year-old Dallas firefighter who had the long-standing mental habit of calculating catastrophes , the better to avoid them .
He sat by exit doors .
He refused to book 11th-floor hotel rooms , because engine ladders only reached 10 .
He taught his kids to avoid escalators , which could snag shoelaces .
Yet Dorety showed no alarm when he and his wife , Susan , climbed aboard the Grand Princess cruise ship at Pier 27 in San Francisco on Friday , Feb. 21 , joining some 2,500 passengers and 1,100 crew members .
It @ @ @ @ @ @ @ to Hawaii , with a brief stop in Ensenada .
The Texas couple had crossed the oceans on dozens of cruises , and this trip was meant to celebrate their 40th anniversary .
His habit of caution , sharpened over decades of answering 911 calls , gave her comfort when they traveled .
“ He always did the what-ifs , ” she said .
“ I can guarantee you , if there were any what-ifs about this trip , he would not have been on there.
” As people boarded , Susan Dorety @ @ @ @ @ @ @ no special precautions , even though there had been a coronavirus outbreak on another company ship , the Diamond Princess , earlier that month in Japan .
The Grand Princess began crossing San Francisco Bay toward the Pacific just before sunset .
Passengers stood in the wind , aiming phones at the Golden Gate Bridge as it passed overhead , and the big horn sounded .
The “ mysterious respiratory illness ” had just acquired its official name 10 days earlier .
The deaths were still mostly in China , with none so @ @ @ @ @ @ @ It was still possible to contain the virus , the director of the World Health Organization said , adding : “ The window of opportunity is narrowing.
” On the Grand Princess , crowds formed at the buffets , grills and pizzerias ; drinkers lifted cosmopolitans and lemontinis at the bars ; the new plague multiplied invisibly among passengers and crew .
So many images now vie to define the time of COVID-19 : Zoom grids .
Ghost-town capitals .
Infection trend lines .
Death behind plexiglass .
The enemy pathogen itself , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ with crimson blooms .
The outbreak aboard the ship is a window on the early days of the pandemic ’ s spread , and of the shifting , improvisational , sometimes fumbling response it engendered .
But it ’ s also a reminder of how wildly the last 10 months have warped time and memory .
Because at the beginning , there was this : a boat circling off the California coast , trying to get home — a 949-foot , 108-ton floating purgatory without a port .
Burly , garrulous Mike Dorety @ @ @ @ @ @ @ emergencies , did not like to stray far from his wife .
“ I need you , ” he ’ d say if she wandered away .
Together they browsed in the gift shops and read on the deck lounge .
When the ship reached Hawaii , they climbed off together to explore .
The mood had grown edgier , in the days it took to cruise 2,500 nautical miles .
Passengers who picked up the Honolulu Star-Advertiser on Feb. 27 saw the headline “ Isle residents stock up on supplies.
” Crowds @ @ @ @ @ @ @ sanitizer and toilet paper .
As the boat turned back to the mainland , it labored through a pounding , deck-rocking storm .
Pool water sloshed over the rim at Neptune ’ s Reef and Pool .
On Wednesday , March 4 , passengers awoke to find the daily newsletter , Princess Patter , announcing “ some of the day ’ s onboard highlights , ” including : A speech about dolphins in the Princess Theater .
A Mexican Fiesta on Deck 5 .
The Marriage Match Game Show on Deck 7 .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ Hills Ice Tea for $ 10 .
And this : A letter from the cruise line ’ s chief medical officer had been slipped under their doors overnight .
It notified passengers that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention was investigating “ a small cluster ” of COVID-19 cases in Northern California connected to a Grand Princess cruise to Mexico a couple of weeks earlier .
Some of the guests from that trip were still on board — back-to-backers , they were called — along with many crew members .
There was @ @ @ @ @ @ @ it .
But the stop in Ensenada the next day would be canceled — they would head straight to San Francisco .
Soon came more unsettling news .
California was reporting what was believed at the time to be its first COVID-19 death .
It was “ an elderly adult with underlying health conditions ” from Placer County , and he had been on the Grand Princess trip to Mexico .
“ Other cruise passengers may have also been exposed , ” the news release said .
The Doretys , who were in @ @ @ @ @ @ @ they had some back-to-backers in their hallway .
The couple had chatted with them , and taken note of their tans from the sunny Mexico trip .
Now the Doretys wondered now where the Placer County man had stayed on the ship .
Which dining rooms had he visited ?
Who were his waiters ?
Were they still on board ?
Was the virus on board too ?
Similar questions were going through the mind of Monica Achter , 52 , an artist from Layton , Utah , who was staying in room @ @ @ @ @ @ @ was her first cruise , and she was traveling with her parents .
Even as people kept crowding into restaurants and cafes and lounges , she noticed deck attendants with yellow buckets scrubbing surfaces by the elevators .
She was struck by a new , pervasive quiet .
“ We just looked at each other like any of us could be infected , ” she would write in a memoir of the experience .
“ It was like trying to go back to normal after learning there was a murder on the ship @ @ @ @ @ @ @ the killer .
There was an air of accusation floating in every interaction.
” The captain , John Harry Smith , whose regular Messages from the Deck were piped into rooms and restaurants and cafes across the ship , had reassured people through the storm in a calm and sonorous British accent .
He was not one of those cruise-ship captains who interacted with guests only when obliged .
He was known to mingle and pose for photos .
Now he came on to announce that big gatherings would be curbed , on @ @ @ @ @ @ @ an abundance of caution , we have regretfully made the decision to cancel this evening ’ s Captain ’ s Circle party as well as the entertainment activities of “ Born to Dance ” and Marriage Match… The captain was from Cheltenham , England , the newsletter informed passengers , and had joined the Merchant Navy as a deck boy in 1983 .
He had been with “ the Princess family ” since 2007 .
Our entertainment team is working to have a copy of “ Born to Dance ” loaded onto our @ @ @ @ @ @ @ so that you can enjoy this wonderful show from the comfort of your stateroom… We recognize the last days of this cruise are not what we all hoped for from our guests… Mike and Susan Dorety went to dinner that night , drank martinis at the bar and chatted with fellow passengers .
On Thursday , Princess Patter promised vestiges of normalcy on Deck 7 that night : the Miracle Lyrical Game Show , then the Missing Spaces Game Show ( “ another night of laughter !
” ) , then Karaoke Fun @ @ @ @ @ @ @ different by the time she and her husband got to the breakfast buffet .
You couldn ’ t scoop your eggs onto your own plate — servers were now doing it for you .
The salt and pepper shakers had been removed .
And if you wanted sugar in your coffee , you had to flag someone down .
Achter , the memoirist in B628 , did water aerobics in the hot tub and lunched with her parents .
She was standing in line at the internet cafe when a woman coughed , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ — hurriedly explained : “ It ’ s OK , I ’ m not sick.
” Here came a helicopter , with medical staff climbing on board to take samples of 46 passengers and crew deemed most likely to have been exposed .
Mike Dorety was not among them ; he felt fine .
In an abundance of caution today they have asked us to implement additional recommendations… Now Smith was saying that all social gatherings would be canceled .
The bars and boutiques , the gym and casino , closed .
The @ @ @ @ @ @ @ remain in their staterooms for the remainder of the cruise .
This will be disappointing to hear .
However , after lunch today , we ask that you return to your staterooms… .
On video of the moment , passengers can be heard reacting with groans .
The Doretys watched people taking food back to their rooms .
From now on , they ’ d have to depend on room service .
For those with balcony rooms , there was still ocean air ; for those in cheaper inside rooms , for the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ nights in confinement would become hard to tell apart .
As a reminder , we do not have any confirmed cases of Covid-19 on the Grand Princess… The boat would not be allowed to dock in San Francisco .
It was too close to the crowds of the Embarcadero .
Passengers heard rumors of someone threatening to blow up the ship if it docked .
To make this time easier we have added more content to our on-demand entertainment programming , and increased the ship ’ s internet bandwidth… Friday ’ s Princess @ @ @ @ @ @ @ that Steve ’ s Quiz of the Day would be one of the in-room offerings .
We are presently cruising approximately 47 miles off the coast of California in something of a holding pattern .
Sea conditions are good and the weather overcast , but no rain today so far , so good news .
Ship remains safe and secure… Passengers saw the ship making a peculiar pattern on the screens tracing its trajectory .
“ We ’ re circling , ” everyone said .
But the shape of their watery limbo was @ @ @ @ @ @ @ sides , traced and retraced .
We have added 100 new movies to your television ’ s on-demand menu and they ’ re in the process of delivering an activity kit to each stateroom .
Remember it is important to stretch your mind and body regularly… The captain said he was awaiting word from health authorities about the results of yesterday ’ s virus tests .
It was Vice President Mike Pence , however , who announced the “ very difficult results ” that afternoon on TV .
“ Twenty-one individuals on the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ said .
“ Among those were 19 crew members and two passengers.
” It was not yet clear where the ship would be allowed to dock , but it would be “ a noncommercial port , ” he said .
Into the rooms came the captain ’ s voice about 35 minutes later , reiterating the vice president ’ s message with a hint of frustration .
You may have heard this on the news by the media already , and we apologize but we were not given advance notice of this announcement @ @ @ @ @ @ @ would have been our preference to be the first to make this news available to you… President Trump was touring the CDC in Atlanta , where he announced that the virus was thus far confined to just 240 cases in the United States .
“ We ’ ve had 11 deaths , and they ’ ve been largely old people , ” Trump said .
“ What should be done about that cruise ship ?
” a reporter asked .
The president said they were weighing options , but it was his preference @ @ @ @ @ @ @ “ I like the numbers being where they are , ” Trump said .
“ I don ’ t need to have the number double because of one ship.
” This was a demoralizing moment for some passengers .
“ It made me feel like I was abandoned , ” said Cheri Harris , 63 , who was in room C629 on the Caribe deck with her husband , Alfred .
“ ‘ OK , you are an inconvenience now — you are unimportant.
’ ” Harris said her husband was angry about @ @ @ @ @ @ @ scene .
“ He was super angry when they wouldn ’ t let us get any fresh air .
He was ready to storm the customer service desk .
‘ I have rights .
They can ’ t force me to stay in this cabin.
’ I talked him down off the ledge .
I said : ‘ Guess what ?
There is a brig on this ship , and if you make a fool of yourself [ they ’ ll ] put you in the brig.
’ ” She and her husband @ @ @ @ @ @ @ arts and crafts and the trivia competitions .
She had taken a ukulele lesson , and they were looking forward to participating in the big talent show , now canceled .
“ We called it Voyage of the Damned , Plague Ship , ” said Harris , who would remain a cruise-ship enthusiast even after the experience .
“ We had all kinds of terms of endearment for our cruise.
” On Saturday , March 7 , Smith reassured guests they ’ d be home as soon as possible .
The Princess was @ @ @ @ @ @ @ the onboard hula-dancing instructor , helped the crew cobble together activity packages every morning to drop off at passengers ’ rooms .
Assembly lines would form ; in went crossword puzzles , decks of cards , improvised origami paper .
“ It was really kind of scrounging , ” said Vasquez , who along with her husband , the ukulele teacher , had worked on the Grand Princess for years .
“ We kind of fly by the seat of our pants , ” she said .
“ As Hawaiians , you kind @ @ @ @ @ @ @ don ’ t get upset over things you have no control over.
” California Gov .
Gavin Newsom ’ s office had been in secret discussions with Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf .
The governor and federal officials had settled on Oakland as the docking point .
“ He walked me through why they wanted to dock the ship in Oakland , ” Schaaf recalled .
“ My immediate reaction was : ‘ Why was it not going to its home berth in San Francisco ?
Is this not just a continuation of the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Oakland ?
’ ” The Oakland port was not meant for cruise ships — it was one of California ’ s busiest ports , with about a million cargo containers coming in every year and another million going out .
But the site was in an industrial area , away from crowds , and could be fenced off .
Schaaf said OK .
The logistical effort would be massive .
Along with more than 2,000 Americans , the ship had guests from 23 nations and a crew from more than 40 , including @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Philippines , according to the CDC .
They would need to wait for their countries to send planes to repatriate them .
The Americans would quarantine at military bases .
There were about 1,000 Californians , who would go to in-state bases , while the other Americans would fly to Georgia and Texas .
Danny Wan , the Oakland port director , recalled the effort as “ a hurricane of uncertainty and activity , ” one that in some ways foreshadowed the year ahead .
“ It was really a crash introduction to @ @ @ @ @ @ @ ” he said .
“ There wasn ’ t a lot of ramping up .
There was just , ‘ Here it is.
’ ” The Oakland plan was announced at a news conference on Sunday , March 8 .
Smith told passengers that disembarkation was expected to take two or three days .
As you know , this is a rather fluid situation… We ’ ve been approved to begin a program to rotate guests and to get some fresh air and sunlight .
We will share details shortly… On shore , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ struggling to find out what was happening .
Robin Clawson , a Santa Cruz resident , learned that her parents were stuck on the boat and launched a Facebook page so people could exchange information .
“ They didn ’ t have a way to communicate with each other , ” she said .
“ It was just a big cluster from the very beginning.
” In L222 , the Doretys were packed and ready .
Mike was irritated .
He wanted to get back to Texas , back to the sheep he @ @ @ @ @ @ @ outside Fort Worth .
He was tired of cruise ship food .
“ I ’ m ready for a Whataburger , ” he said .
“ I ’ m ready to be home.
” The Grand Princess passed under the Golden Gate Bridge on Monday , March 9 , and cheers erupted on board .
Alcatraz Island appeared up ahead , and among passengers there were jokes that the government had the old prison pegged as their new home .
Mike Dorety had awakened that morning drenched with sweat .
He showered and @ @ @ @ @ @ @ “ Your dad ’ s sleeping ” a lot , Susan told her son on the mainland .
“ He ’ s really tired of being in here.
” As people were making their way down the gangplank in assigned groups , she was trying to keep her husband covered with towels and robes and a comforter , but he wouldn ’ t stop shaking .
She said she called the ship ’ s 911 line multiple times , pleading for help , and was told a report would be filled out .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ get off the boat .
By Tuesday , March 10 , the second day of disembarkation , the captain ’ s voice had an unmistakable edge .
Plans kept changing without notice , to his frustration .
We have not been receiving timely nor accurate information from the government agencies who have developed and are managing the disembarkation plan… Susan Dorety said a ship doctor came by her room to take her husband ’ s temperature and dropped off a box of Tamiflu , but it didn ’ t seem to help .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ from him , ” she recalled .
“ I called again and said : ‘ He ’ s not any better .
...
He ’ s not talking to me .
He ’ s not responding .
Somebody ’ s got to come help him.
’ ” They got him to sick bay early that evening , she said , and soon after wheeled him down the gangplank .
She said her husband was so ill that he could not tell medics his name or remember his birthday .
“ They got the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ she said .
“ They looked at me and said , ‘ Why did it take you so long to get him off ?
’ Like it was my fault.
” She said she was made to return to her room on the boat .
“ As they loaded him on the ambulance he was waving .
He kept trying to get me to come on the ambulance with me and they wouldn ’ t let me.
” By the end of Wednesday , March 11 , the day the World Health Organization @ @ @ @ @ @ @ than 2,000 passengers had gotten off the boat .
The captain explained that disembarking others hinged on the availability of government-booked charter flights .
I understand there is a lot of frustration with still being on board… The situation is beyond my staff ’ s control… In all , 115 people who had been on board tested positive , and 31 required hospitalization , according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services .
Among passengers , there is suspicion that the virus spread not just on the ship but on the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ to two-week quarantine .
Achter , the memoirist from Utah , recalled sitting on a bus for hours waiting on a tarmac for her flight to the Dobbins Air Reserve Base in Georgia with her parents .
After days of isolation in a ship cabin , it was hard to find the logic in it .
“ They cram us all together on this bus , ” she said .
“ Then on this charter airplane , we were all sitting by each other there too.
” Racked by stress , she landed @ @ @ @ @ @ @ she had to be carried off the plane .
But her main worry was her 71-year-old mother , who had diabetes and had been rationing her insulin for days .
Now her mom lay in bed , too fatigued to move , her blood sugar alarmingly high , her empty insulin pen in her hand .
Achter said she kept pleading with the base pharmacist for help , and the day after their arrival — Saturday night — a nurse arrived with the shot that saved her mother .
At bases across the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ large and small , were playing out in quarantine behind chain-link fences , under floodlights , in the shadow of armed federal guards .
At Travis Air Force Base , where the monotony of turkey sandwiches was a frequent complaint , a widower who had been in room B206 on the boat spent $ 5,800 to have 475 Dominoes cheese pizzas delivered to his companions in quarantine .
Susan Dorety was at Travis too , awaiting news of her husband , who was being treated at the Kaiser hospital in Oakland .
She @ @ @ @ @ @ @ , that he was being put into a coma , that his body wasn ’ t getting oxygen , that his organs were shutting down .
“ It turned his lungs to rocks , ” she said .
He died on March 20 , one of six Americans on the Grand Princess killed by complications from the virus , according to HHS .
Five were passengers ; one was a crew member .
The outbreak on the cruise ship has sparked a flurry of lawsuits , including a wrongful-death claim from the Dorety @ @ @ @ @ @ @ sensitive to the difficulties the COVID-19 outbreak has caused to our guests and crew , ” the company said in a statement .
“ Our response throughout this process has focused on the well-being of our guests and crew within the parameters dictated to us by the government agencies involved and the evolving medical understanding of this new illness.
” The cruise line said it will not discuss pending litigation .
“ If there were any precautions at the beginning of this , my overcautious husband would have backpedaled so fast , ” @ @ @ @ @ @ @ hard and he was everybody ’ s protector .
What ’ s so hard is nobody could take care of him when he needed it .
He was all alone .
”

Michael Dorety was a retired 68-year-old Dallas firefighter who had the long-standing mental habit of calculating catastrophes, the better to avoid them. He sat by exit doors. He refused to book 11th-floor hotel rooms, because engine ladders only reached 10. He taught his kids to avoid escalators, which could snag shoelaces.
Yet Dorety showed no alarm when he and his wife, Susan, climbed aboard the Grand Princess cruise ship at Pier 27 in San Francisco on Friday, Feb. 21, joining some 2,500 passengers and 1,100 crew members. It was supposed to be a 15-day cruise to Hawaii, with a brief stop in Ensenada.
The Texas couple had crossed the oceans on dozens of cruises, and this trip was meant to celebrate their 40th anniversary.
His habit of caution, sharpened over decades of answering 911 calls, gave her comfort when they traveled. “He always did the what-ifs,” she said. “I can guarantee you, if there were any what-ifs about this trip, he would not have been on there.”
As people boarded, Susan Dorety recalled, the ship seemed to take no special precautions, even though there had been a coronavirus outbreak on another company ship, the Diamond Princess, earlier that month in Japan.
Advertisement
The Grand Princess began crossing San Francisco Bay toward the Pacific just before sunset. Passengers stood in the wind, aiming phones at the Golden Gate Bridge as it passed overhead, and the big horn sounded.
The “mysterious respiratory illness” had just acquired its official name 10 days earlier. The deaths were still mostly in China, with none so far reported in the United States. It was still possible to contain the virus, the director of the World Health Organization said, adding: “The window of opportunity is narrowing.”
On the Grand Princess, crowds formed at the buffets, grills and pizzerias; drinkers lifted cosmopolitans and lemontinis at the bars; the new plague multiplied invisibly among passengers and crew.
So many images now vie to define the time of COVID-19: Zoom grids. Ghost-town capitals. Infection trend lines. Death behind plexiglass. The pathogen itself, depicted as a pocked little asteroid bristling with crimson blooms.
The outbreak aboard the ship is a window on the early days of the pandemic’s spread, and of the shifting, improvisational, sometimes fumbling response it engendered.
But it’s also a reminder of how wildly the last 10 months have warped time and memory. Because at the beginning, there was this: a boat circling off the California coast, trying to get home — a 949-foot, 108,000-ton floating purgatory without a port.
::
Burly, garrulous Mike Dorety, a steady hand in so many emergencies, did not like to stray far from his wife. “I need you,” he’d say if she wandered away. Together they browsed in the gift shops and read on the deck lounge. When the ship reached Hawaii, they climbed off together to explore.
The mood had grown edgier, in the days it took to cruise 2,500 nautical miles. Passengers who picked up the Honolulu Star-Advertiser on Feb. 27 saw the headline “Isle residents stock up on supplies.” Crowds were besieging big-box stores to grab hand sanitizer and toilet paper.
Advertisement
Mike and Susan Dorety aboard the Grand Princess cruise ship. (Susan Dorety)
As the boat turned back to the mainland, it labored through a pounding, deck-rocking storm. Pool water sloshed over the rim at Neptune’s Reef and Pool.
On Wednesday, March 4, passengers awoke to find the daily newsletter, Princess Patter, announcing “some of the day’s onboard highlights,” including: A speech about dolphins in the Princess Theater. A Mexican Fiesta on Deck 5. The Marriage Match Game Show on Deck 7. The Drink of the Day was Beverly Hills Ice Tea for $10.
And another communication: A letter from the cruise line’s chief medical officer had been slipped under their doors overnight. It notified passengers that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention was investigating “a small cluster” of COVID-19 cases in Northern California connected to a Grand Princess cruise to Mexico a couple of weeks earlier.
Some of the guests from that trip were still on board — back-to-backers, they were called — along with many crew members.
There was no indication that anyone on board had it. But the stop in Ensenada the next day would be canceled — they would head straight to San Francisco.
Advertisement
Soon came more unsettling news. California was reporting what was believed at the time to be its first COVID-19 death. It was “an elderly adult with underlying health conditions” from Placer County, and he had been on the Grand Princess trip to Mexico. “Other cruise passengers may have also been exposed,” the news release said.
The Doretys, who were in L222 on the Lido deck, knew they had some back-to-backers in their hallway. The couple had chatted with them, and taken note of their tans from the sunny Mexico trip.
Now the Doretys wondered where the Placer County man had stayed on the ship. Which dining rooms had he visited? Who were his waiters? Were they still on board? Was the virus on board too?
Similar questions were going through the mind of Monica Achter, 52, an artist from Layton, Utah, who was staying in room B628 on the Baja deck. It was her first cruise, and she was traveling with her parents.
Even as people kept crowding into restaurants and cafes and lounges, she noticed deck attendants with yellow buckets scrubbing surfaces by the elevators. She was struck by a new, pervasive quiet.
“We just looked at each other like any of us could be infected,” she would write in a memoir of the experience. “It was like trying to go back to normal after learning there was a murder on the ship and any one of us could be the killer. There was an air of accusation floating in every interaction.”
The captain, John Harry Smith, whose regular Messages from the Deck were piped into rooms and restaurants and cafes across the ship, had reassured people through the storm in a calm and sonorous British accent. He was not one of those cruise-ship captains who interacted with guests only when obliged. He was known to mingle and pose for photos. Now he came on to announce that big gatherings would be curbed, on the advice of the CDC.
Advertisement
In an abundance of caution, we have regretfully made the decision to cancel this evening’s Captain’s Circle party as well as the entertainment activities of “Born to Dance” and Marriage Match…
The captain was from Cheltenham, England, the newsletter informed passengers, and had joined the Merchant Navy as a deck boy in 1983. He had been with “the Princess family” since 2007.
Our entertainment team is working to have a copy of “Born to Dance” loaded onto our video-on-demand platform along with other new programming so that you can enjoy this wonderful show from the comfort of your stateroom… We recognize the last days of this cruise are not what we all hoped for from our guests…
Mike and Susan Dorety went to dinner that night, drank martinis at the bar and chatted with fellow passengers.
On Thursday, Princess Patter promised vestiges of normalcy on Deck 7 that night: the Miracle Lyrical Game Show, then the Missing Spaces Game Show (“another night of laughter!”), then Karaoke Fun.
But Susan Dorety knew things were different by the time she and her husband got to the breakfast buffet. You couldn’t scoop your eggs onto your own plate — servers were now doing it for you. The salt and pepper shakers had been removed. And if you wanted sugar in your coffee, you had to flag someone down.
Advertisement
Achter, the memoirist in B628, did water aerobics in the hot tub and lunched with her parents. She was standing in line at the internet cafe when a woman coughed, then — because it was now necessary — hurriedly explained: “It’s OK, I’m not sick.”
Here came a helicopter, with medical staff climbing on board to take samples of 46 passengers and crew deemed most likely to have been exposed. Mike Dorety was not among them; he felt fine.
In an abundance of caution today they have asked us to implement additional recommendations…
The Grand Princess cruise ship passed under the Golden Gate Bridge to dock at the Port of Oakland on March 9. (Peter DaSilva / For The Times)
Now Smith was saying that all social gatherings would be canceled. The bars and boutiques, the gym and casino, closed.
Advertisement
The CDC has also recommended that guests should remain in their staterooms for the remainder of the cruise. This will be disappointing to hear. However, after lunch today, we ask that you return to your staterooms….
On video of the moment, passengers can be heard reacting with groans. The Doretys watched people taking food back to their rooms. From now on, they’d have to depend on room service.
For those with balcony rooms, there was still ocean air; for those in cheaper inside rooms, for the rooms without windows, the days and nights in confinement would become hard to tell apart.
As a reminder, we do not have any confirmed cases of Covid-19 on the Grand Princess…
VIDEO | 00:43 Listen to captain: ‘We will certainly keep you informed’ Grand Princess Capt. Robert Smith updates passengers about how the ship is responding to a possible coronavirus outbreak onboard.
The boat would not be allowed to dock in San Francisco. It was too close to the crowds of the Embarcadero. Passengers heard rumors of someone threatening to blow up the ship if it docked.
Advertisement
To make this time easier we have added more content to our on-demand entertainment programming, and increased the ship’s internet bandwidth…
Friday’s Princess Patter was threadbare of fun but advised that Steve’s Quiz of the Day would be one of the in-room offerings.
We are presently cruising approximately 47 miles off the coast of California in something of a holding pattern. Sea conditions are good and the weather overcast, but no rain today so far, so good news. Ship remains safe and secure…
Passengers saw the ship making a peculiar pattern on the screens tracing its trajectory. “We’re circling,” everyone said. But the shape of their watery limbo was really a vast rectangle with incredible ruler-straight sides, traced and retraced.
We have added 100 new movies to your television’s on-demand menu and they’re in the process of delivering an activity kit to each stateroom. Remember it is important to stretch your mind and body regularly…
The captain said he was awaiting word from health authorities about the results of yesterday’s virus tests. It was Vice President Mike Pence, however, who announced the “very difficult results” that afternoon on TV.
Advertisement
“Twenty-one individuals on the Grand Princess tested positive,” Pence said. “Among those were 19 crew members and two passengers.” It was not yet clear where the ship would be allowed to dock, but it would be “a noncommercial port,” he said.
Into the rooms came the captain’s voice about 35 minutes later, reiterating the vice president’s message with a hint of frustration.
You may have heard this on the news by the media already, and we apologize but we were not given advance notice of this announcement by the U.S. federal government. It would have been our preference to be the first to make this news available to you…
President Trump was touring the CDC in Atlanta, where he announced that the virus was thus far confined to just 240 cases in the United States.
“We’ve had 11 deaths, and they’ve been largely old people,” Trump said.
“What should be done about that cruise ship?” a reporter asked.
The president said they were weighing options, but it was his preference to keep the passengers on board.
Advertisement
“I like the numbers being where they are,” Trump said. “I don’t need to have the number double because of one ship.”
Grand Princess passengers Cheri and Alfred Harris with Capt. John Smith, right. (Harris family)
This was a demoralizing moment for some passengers. “It made me feel like I was abandoned,” said Cheri Harris, 63, who was in room C629 on the Caribe deck with her husband, Alfred. “‘OK, you are an inconvenience now — you are unimportant.’”
Harris said her husband was angry about the confinement and wanted to make a scene. “He was super angry when they wouldn’t let us get any fresh air. He was ready to storm the customer service desk. ‘I have rights. They can’t force me to stay in this cabin.’ I talked him down off the ledge. I said: ‘Guess what? There is a brig on this ship, and if you make a fool of yourself [they’ll] put you in the brig.’”
She and her husband were veteran cruisers who had enjoyed the arts and crafts and the trivia competitions. She had taken a ukulele lesson, and they were looking forward to participating in the big talent show, now canceled.
“We called it Voyage of the Damned, Plague Ship,” said Harris, who would remain a cruise-ship enthusiast even after the experience. “We had all kinds of terms of endearment for our cruise.”
On Saturday, March 7, Smith reassured guests they’d be home as soon as possible.
Advertisement
We understand your frustration…
The Princess was scrambling to improvise. Rowena Vasquez, the onboard hula-dancing instructor, helped the crew cobble together activity packages every morning to drop off at passengers’ rooms. Assembly lines would form; in went crossword puzzles, decks of cards, improvised origami paper.
“It was really kind of scrounging,” said Vasquez, who along with her husband, the ukulele teacher, had worked on the Grand Princess for years.
“We kind of fly by the seat of our pants,” she said. “As Hawaiians, you kind of ride the waves, and you don’t get upset over things you have no control over.”
::
California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s office had been in secret discussions with Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf. The governor and federal officials had settled on Oakland as the docking point.
“He walked me through why they wanted to dock the ship in Oakland,” Schaaf recalled. “My immediate reaction was: ‘Why was it not going to its home berth in San Francisco? Is this not just a continuation of the unjust history of dumping environmental hazards in Oakland?’”
Advertisement
The Oakland port was not meant for cruise ships — it was one of California’s busiest ports, with about a million cargo containers coming in every year and another million going out. But the site was in an industrial area, away from crowds, and could be fenced off. Schaaf said OK.
The logistical effort would be massive. Along with more than 2,000 Americans, the ship had guests from 23 nations and a crew from more than 40, including more than 500 crew members from the Philippines, according to the CDC. They would need to wait for their countries to send planes to repatriate them.
The Americans would quarantine at military bases. There were about 1,000 Californians, who would go to in-state bases, while the other Americans would fly to Georgia and Texas.
Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf talks to reporters about the arrival of the Grand Princess cruise ship. (Rich Pedroncelli / Associated Press)
Danny Wan, the Oakland port director, recalled the effort as “a hurricane of uncertainty and activity,” one that in some ways foreshadowed the year ahead.
“It was really a crash introduction to the emergency that still exists today,” he said. “There wasn’t a lot of ramping up. There was just, ‘Here it is.’”
The Oakland plan was announced at a news conference on Sunday, March 8. Smith told passengers that disembarkation was expected to take two or three days.
Advertisement
As you know, this is a rather fluid situation…
Let’s all stay strong together…
We’ve been approved to begin a program to rotate guests and to get some fresh air and sunlight. We will share details shortly…
On shore, friends and loved ones and relatives were struggling to find out what was happening. Robin Clawson, a Santa Cruz resident, learned that her parents were stuck on the boat and launched a Facebook page so people could exchange information.
“They didn’t have a way to communicate with each other,” she said. “It was just a big cluster from the very beginning.”
::
In L222, the Doretys were packed and ready. Mike was irritated. He wanted to get back to Texas, back to the sheep he had been raising on his three acres outside Fort Worth. He was tired of cruise ship food.
Advertisement
“I’m ready for a Whataburger,” he said. “I’m ready to be home.”
The Grand Princess passed under the Golden Gate Bridge on Monday, March 9, and cheers erupted on board.
Alcatraz Island appeared up ahead, and among passengers there were jokes that the government had the old prison pegged as their new home.
Mike Dorety had awakened that morning drenched with sweat. He showered and changed and went back to sleep.
“Your dad’s sleeping” a lot, Susan told her son on the mainland. “He’s really tired of being in here.”
As people were making their way down the gangplank in assigned groups, she was trying to keep her husband covered with towels and robes and a comforter, but he wouldn’t stop shaking.
She said she called the ship’s 911 line multiple times, pleading for help, and was told a report would be filled out. They had to wait their turn to get off the boat.
By Tuesday, March 10, the second day of disembarkation, the captain’s voice had an unmistakable edge. Plans kept changing without notice, to his frustration.
We have not been receiving timely nor accurate information from the government agencies who have developed and are managing the disembarkation plan…
Advertisement
Susan Dorety said a ship doctor came by her room to take her husband’s temperature and dropped off a box of Tamiflu, but it didn’t seem to help.
“I was getting a blank look from him,” she recalled. “I called again and said: ‘He’s not any better. ... He’s not talking to me. He’s not responding. Somebody’s got to come help him.’”
They got him to sick bay early that evening, she said, and soon after wheeled him down the gangplank. She said her husband was so ill that he could not tell medics his name or remember his birthday.
“They got the same empty look I got,” she said. “They looked at me and said, ‘Why did it take you so long to get him off?’ Like it was my fault.”
She said she was made to return to her room on the boat.
“As they loaded him on the ambulance he was waving. He kept trying to get me to come on the ambulance with me and they wouldn’t let me.”
By the end of Wednesday, March 11, the day the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a global pandemic, more than 2,000 passengers had gotten off the boat.
Advertisement
The captain explained that disembarking others hinged on the availability of government-booked charter flights.
I understand there is a lot of frustration with still being on board… The situation is beyond my staff’s control…
In all, 115 people who had been on board tested positive, and 31 required hospitalization, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Among passengers, there is suspicion that the virus spread not just on the ship but on the big passenger buses and planes carrying them to two-week quarantine.
Medical personnel help transport passengers from the Grand Princess onto airplanes at Oakland International Airport on March 10. (Josh Edelson / AFP/Getty Images)
Achter, the memoirist from Utah, recalled sitting on a bus for hours waiting on a tarmac for her flight to the Dobbins Air Reserve Base in Georgia with her parents. After days of isolation in a ship cabin, it was hard to find the logic in it.
Advertisement
“They cram us all together on this bus,” she said. “Then on this charter airplane, we were all sitting by each other there too.”
Racked by stress, she landed at Dobbins with a migraine so vicious she had to be carried off the plane. But her main worry was her 71-year-old mother, who had diabetes and had been rationing her insulin for days. Now her mom lay in bed, too fatigued to move, her blood sugar alarmingly high, her empty insulin pen in her hand.
Achter said she kept pleading with the base pharmacist for help, and the day after their arrival — Saturday night — a nurse arrived with the shot that saved her mother.
At bases across the country, thousands of other dramas, large and small, were playing out in quarantine behind chain-link fences, under floodlights, in the shadow of armed federal guards. At Travis Air Force Base, where the monotony of turkey sandwiches was a frequent complaint, a widower who had been in room B206 on the boat spent $5,800 to have 475 Domino’s cheese pizzas delivered to his companions in quarantine.
Susan Dorety was at Travis too, awaiting news of her husband, who was being treated at the Kaiser hospital in Oakland. She got word that he had the virus, that he was being put into a coma, that his body wasn’t getting oxygen, that his organs were shutting down. “It turned his lungs to rocks,” she said.
He died on March 20, one of six Americans on the Grand Princess killed by complications from the virus, according to HHS. Five were passengers; one was a crew member.
The outbreak on the cruise ship has sparked a flurry of lawsuits, including a wrongful-death claim from the Dorety family.
“Princess Cruises has been sensitive to the difficulties the COVID-19 outbreak has caused to our guests and crew,” the company said in a statement. “Our response throughout this process has focused on the well-being of our guests and crew within the parameters dictated to us by the government agencies involved and the evolving medical understanding of this new illness.”
Advertisement
The cruise line said it will not discuss pending litigation.
“If there were any precautions at the beginning of this, my overcautious husband would have backpedaled so fast,” Susan Dorety said. “He loved hard and he was everybody’s protector. What’s so hard is nobody could take care of him when he needed it. He was all alone.”