healthimpactnews--2020-04-28--Teenage Girl Who Had Her Life Destroyed by HPV Vaccine Writes to School Head who Takes Her Side – St

Teenage Girl Who Had Her Life Destroyed by HPV Vaccine Writes to School Head who Takes Her Side – Stands for Right to Refuse Vaccine

[ Note from the SaneVax Team : We would like to thank Chloe and Lisa for granting us permission to publish their story .
This account should help people remember that every major improvement in the human condition began with a single voice .
Hopefully , it will be circulated widely to encourage all those who believe their voice will not be heard .
A teenaged girl from Hertfordshire in the United Kingdom sent the following letter to the headmaster of her school after seeing a huge poster promoting the use of HPV vaccines in her school .
Chloe had @ @ @ @ @ @ @ conditions after taking the full series of HPV vaccines , nearly three years .
She viewed the poster , not only as a personal insult , but one that could put her classmates at risk of having an experience similar to hers .
Think about it : How many times have you been confronted with an issue that seemed too big for you to tackle ?
How many times have you said to yourself , “ I am only one person , what can I do ?
” How many times have you @ @ @ @ @ @ @ speak ?
Much to her credit , Chloe did not stand idly by .
She took action .
By doing so , Chloe proved to the world that one single voice can make a huge difference .
Not only did her headmaster listen , he responded with compassion and concern for Chloe as well as her fellow students .
Chloe ’ s headmaster response shows that when openly communicated with , there are people who listen and respond appropriately .
This story proves the only voice not heard is the one that is @ @ @ @ @ @ @ & I ’ m one of your Year 11 students .
My reason for this email is to tell you that I ’ ve been extremely upset & feel very hurt that my feelings haven ’ t been considered regarding having the extremely large promoting HPV vaccine poster up in school .
As far as I ’ m aware everyone in school as in teaching staff & my group of friends know what caused me to become ill .
I first saw this poster on Friday & it has been on my mind @ @ @ @ @ @ @ that I was going to ask who was responsible for advertising within the school & how it had upset me .
I felt I needed to deal with this situation myself & not just getting them to call the school .
So , I went to pastoral this afternoon , as I wasn ’ t in this morning as didn ’ t feel great Sunday afternoon or yesterday at school & hadn ’ t slept so I came in at break .
Mr. ******** saw me in there he came & looked at @ @ @ @ @ @ @ to you & the caretakers about it .
So , I ’ ve taken it upon myself to email you .
You probably don ’ t know me or my background but since having the HPV vaccine in July 2017 ( when I was in Year 8 ) I became unwell straight after that vaccine .
When I walked in that room to have it , that was the last time I felt 100 % well .
I kept fainting & feeling constantly dizzy , mum phoned the Doctors to ask if it @ @ @ @ @ @ @ was told no by the receptionist .
I got worse so went to the Doctors , said my blood pressure was very low but my heart rate was fast & instead of doing a blood test as I hate needles to leave it a few weeks once the vaccine was out of body & hopefully , I would feel better .
This didn ’ t happen .
I just got worse .
Had blood tests & hospital appointments , but still I got worse .
I remember my Dad asking the cardiologist at @ @ @ @ @ @ @ POTS as they had been looking into my symptoms & found many girls suffered the same as me after the vaccine & had reached out to others .
She basically laughed saying no & to go back in 4 months if no improvement but to drink at least 3 liters of water & 10g of salt ( this is what people with POTS are told to do . )
I was so upset as she didn ’ t help , it wasn ’ t long after my mum took me back to the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ worse still .
He was the best I had seen since our family GP had retired & agreed it was possible that all my symptoms were pointing to POTS so said he would start treating me instead of waiting for tests as I would have to suffer longer & hopefully , I would improve .
I will never forget my Dad talking to the cardiologist after she returned his call when he said he wasn ’ t happy & that she was lucky he wasn ’ t putting in a formal complaint about @ @ @ @ @ @ @ said what the GP gave me is what she would have given me if I had gone back in 4 months to see her .
She kept saying sorry to my Dad & asked how he knew so much .
He told her had you had a fit & healthy child then they had a vaccine & suddenly became ill straight after & no Doctors are really helping or giving answers wouldn ’ t u look for answers yourself ( I remember my mum looking online while sitting up with me during the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ cry when I felt so ill & had enough ) When Dad asked her if my symptoms were linked to the HPV vaccine , she said it ’ s thought to be linked but she can ’ t comment & wouldn ’ t put it in writing .
What hope do people like me have when even Doctors treat us like this ?
?
?
I lost my last two summer holidays as I was in bed .
Before this I was a very active person , I love to dance , do @ @ @ @ @ @ @ I had to stop dancing which I was really good at & loved doing , I could no longer go to the Gym 2/3 times a week & I loved doing PE but now I have to just sit & watch as my friends all get to do it .
A list of my symptoms ( when it started ) • Constantly dizzy ( having to hold myself up on furniture as couldn ’ t stand up ) • Fainting ( would lose count this happened lots but I learnt when it was @ @ @ @ @ @ @ • Heart palpitations ( swear my heart was coming out of my chest & would hurt ) • Tremors in my legs & arms ( remember one of the office ladies thought I was cold but it was my tremors ) • Chronic fatigue ( literally couldn ’ t stay awake at my worst point or hold my own head up off the pillow ) • Heat intolerance ( I can ’ t cope with temperature change when I get hot I instantly feel rough & it knocks me back , can take @ @ @ @ @ @ @ • Pale in the face ( unable to get a tan at all now ) • No awareness of what ’ s going on around me , like I go off in my own world • Unable to stand for anytime ( when I ’ m in science doing experiments , I have to either sit down or lean on the side as it makes me feel rough ) Having to live with this is hard & I do get upset but I try not to show how upset I am & I @ @ @ @ @ @ @ school counsellor , but I haven ’ t seen her for a while for some reason .
I try to be in school as much as I can .
I ’ m not one of these people that will happily miss school & finger crossed I haven ’ t for some time .
I love being there with my group of friends & when I ’ m not there I feel more upset .
But sometimes it ’ s been impossible when I ’ m so ill , I know mum has told @ @ @ @ @ @ @ to come & see me when I ’ ve been off really ill.
I ’ ve been seeing a lady called Rita since July 2018 , who specializes in girls like me , damaged from the HPV vaccine .
She ’ s treated hundreds of us .
It ’ s only because I was so ill my mum was searching for something that might help as she didn ’ t know what else to do & joined a support group & they were recommending Rita .
The following day my Dad contacted her @ @ @ @ @ @ @ She ’ s so lovely & understands how I feel & believes me .
I ’ m lucky my parents can afford my homeopathy appointments & treatments as some parents can ’ t .
There are so many other girls like me , not just in the UK but around the world .
And boys also in other countries .
I have to remember when I ’ m down that I ’ m lucky as I ’ m not as worse off as others , some paralyzed & others have died after this @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Association of HPV vaccine injured daughters ( AHVID ) they have over 640 UK families on their database , all have injured daughters this includes me .
Someone I know in another school didn ’ t have the HPV vaccine , because of what it did to me .
A close family member of hers is a GP too .
It annoys me that my parents get called anti-vaxxers or accused of scaremongering as they aren ’ t , they have given me every vaccine that ’ s been on offer & my @ @ @ @ @ @ @ want to have the HPV vaccine as I hate needles but my mum thought it was for the best as she had a friend with cervical cancer who ’ s since lost their fight & she thought I wouldn ’ t ever get it then , but now we know this isn ’ t true .
There are women that have had the vaccine & got cervical cancer at a very young age , just we don ’ t really get told about this .
My mum now gets so angry with herself @ @ @ @ @ @ @ this vaccine first before making me have it .
As my parents tell people they ’ re not telling them not to have the vaccine but to look into it first , although this is now being proved very difficult to look into as many of these sites are being shut down which is very sad , scary & frustrating to me .
The amount of times I ’ ve been called faking being ill or people just haven ’ t believed me is really hard for me to deal with .
If @ @ @ @ @ @ @ love to feel normal .
Not only do I have to live with the effects but I ’ m now being reminded of it when I ’ m in school having this poster in my face .
I can not stress how much I really want this poster taken down , as I ’ ve said it ’ s not nice for me to see & if it ’ s not I can get some posters made up regarding side effects that I will quite happily print off & stick next to this @ @ @ @ @ @ @ school as I believe people deserve to know both sides of this vaccine .
I did say to Mr. ******* if I made some of my own posters would I be allowed to put them up , but he didn ’ t comment .
This is something I feel very passionate about & you can ’ t blame me I ’ ve lost so much time being ill & even now “ I ’ m ok ” ( when I say I ’ m ok I ’ m not , I ’ m @ @ @ @ @ @ @ being injured by this vaccine & have to get on with it , as I ’ m sure not everyone wants to hear I ’ m not ok ) I spoke about this for my English language exam at the end of yr. 10 because I feel people deserve the right to know it ’ s not all good .
I was really proud of it & would have liked you to have heard it , it contained information about the manufacturer of the drug & their previous drugs that got banded .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ you would be interested in reading it ?
Sadly , we all get told it ’ s a coincidence that we all have pretty much the same set of symptoms after the vaccine .
I hope you can understand where I ’ m coming from , if not imagine if this happened to your daughter or family member .
I just want you to be aware of what your allowing to be advertised in your school as I ’ m sure if someone was to become ill like me you would feel bad @ @ @ @ @ @ @ has happened to me .
Not everyone puts two & two together to realize why their child is suddenly ill.
I ’ m sorry if you think this email is having a go or comes across harsh or rude to you because that is not my intention , I ’ m just trying to get my point across .
And I ’ m having to do it in an email as if I just spoke to you the likelihood of me forgetting what I want to say is very likely as my memory @ @ @ @ @ @ @ my symptoms I ’ ve been left with .
This email has taken ages from when I got in from school until late & I ’ ve been very emotional writing it , I ’ ve cried every time I ’ ve read back through it .
So please don ’ t just ignore it .
Below I ’ ve put some links .
There ’ s so much more I could add but thought that was enough for now .
Anyway , thank you for reading this sorry it ’ s so @ @ @ @ @ @ @ talk to me , I would be more than happy too .
After my daughter sent her email to the headmaster , she had a meeting with him & we spoke to him over the phone .
The poster was removed , which we all feel was a massive win for her as she was really upset & felt she was having it rubbed in her face .
He told us that the poster is given to the school from the nursing team & he can categorically say the school doesn ’ t @ @ @ @ @ @ @ poster or anything of its kind .
He has removed the poster & will not put it back up unless he is forced to do so by the powers above him , but if that was to be the case he would want answers to some of his questions that he has about it due to us bringing it to his attention as he didn ’ t know there were issues with it .
Also , he would forward us the contact details of whoever it was that tells him to put it @ @ @ @ @ @ @ up with them .
And if it had to go back up , he would talk to us about it first & walk around the school with Chloe to find somewhere in the school that she doesn ’ t go , so that she doesn ’ t have to see it .
He also said he didn ’ t feel the poster needed to be there , as the parents had already had the consent letters .
Also , if a child decided they didn ’ t want the vaccine even after parents @ @ @ @ @ @ @ ’ t be made to have it ( which is good to hear ) He was very apologetic that Chloe was upset about the poster being up & that she felt nobody considered her feelings about putting up the poster .
He said that he would have to have a talk with the team who deals with PSHCE days ( personal social help and citizen education ) to see if it would be possible to have a discussion about reactions to vaccines alongside the topic of climate change , etc.… that they do @ @ @ @ @ @ @ ’ t want Chloe to feel that she was being belittled at all .
Please remember : The only voice that is not heard is the one that is silent .
Comment on this article at VaccineImpact.com .
14-Year-Old Active Girl in Wisconsin Suffers Over 300 Seizures After Gardasil Vaccine – Doctor Refuses to Consider Gardasil Cause due to Fear of Losing Research Funding Illinois Teen Dies Three Weeks After Being Injected with HPV Gardasil Vaccine California Nurse Gives Gardasil Vaccine to Own Daughter who Develops Leukemia and Dies Infant Accidentally Vaccinated with @ @ @ @ @ @ @ and Baby Medically Kidnapped The Happy-go-Lucky Girl I had Pre-HPV Vaccine is Gone Forever Gardasil Vaccine Given without Consent and Ruins Life of 14 Year Old Girl After 3 Years of Suffering 19 Year Old Girl Dies from Gardasil Vaccine Injuries Gardasil : The Decision We Will Always Regret 15 Year Old French Girl ’ s “ Descent into Hell ” After Gardasil Vaccine – Wheelchair Bound and Paralyzed The Gardasil Vaccine After-Life : My Daughter is a Shadow of Her Former Self Gardasil : An Experience no Child Should Have to Go @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Life Back the Way it was Before Gardasil 15-Year-Old Vaccinated by Force with Gardasil now Suffers from Paralysis and Pain Gardasil : We Thought It Was The Right Choice “ HPV Vaccine Has Done This to My Child ” 13 Year Old World Championship Karate Student Forced to Quit After Gardasil Vaccine If I Could Turn Back Time , Korey Would not Have Received any Gardasil Shots What Doctors Don ’ t Tell You : Our Gardasil Horror Story Family Fights U.S. Government over Compensation for Gardasil Vaccine Injuries Gardasil : When Will @ @ @ @ @ @ @ : “ I Can not Begin to Describe What it is Like to Watch your Daughter Live in Such Agony ” Gardasil : Don ’ t Let Your Child Become “ One Less ” The Gardasil Vaccine Changed Our Definition of “ Normal ” Gardasil : I Should Have Researched First “ They ’ ve Been Robbed of Their Womanhood ” – Local Milwaukee Media Covers Gardasil Vaccine Injuries Gardasil : The Decision I will Always Regret After Gardasil : I Simply Want my Healthy Daughter Back Gardasil : My Family Suffers with @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Life , and Family ’ s Lives Forever My Personal Battle After the Gardasil Vaccine Gardasil : The Worst Thing That Ever Happened to Me The Dark Side of Gardasil – A Nightmare that Became Real Leaving a lucrative career as a nephrologist ( kidney doctor ) , Dr. Suzanne Humphries is now free to actually help cure people .
In this autobiography she explains why good doctors are constrained within the current corrupt medical system from practicing real , ethical medicine .
One of the sane voices when it comes to examining @ @ @ @ @ @ @ pro-vaccine extremist doctors have ever dared to debate her in public .
Say NO to Mandatory Vaccines T-Shirt Big Pharma and government health authorities are trying to pass laws mandating vaccines for all children , and even adults .
Show your opposition to forced vaccinations and support the cause of Vaccine Impact , part of the Health Impact News network .

HPV Vaccine Controversy in the UK
Submitted by Lisa Enever, Chloe’s Mother, Hertfordshire UK
SaneVax, Inc.
[Note from the SaneVax Team: We would like to thank Chloe and Lisa for granting us permission to publish their story. This account should help people remember that every major improvement in the human condition began with a single voice. Hopefully, it will be circulated widely to encourage all those who believe their voice will not be heard.
A teenaged girl from Hertfordshire in the United Kingdom sent the following letter to the headmaster of her school after seeing a huge poster promoting the use of HPV vaccines in her school. Chloe had been suffering a multitude of new medical conditions after taking the full series of HPV vaccines, nearly three years. She viewed the poster, not only as a personal insult, but one that could put her classmates at risk of having an experience similar to hers.
Think about it: How many times have you been confronted with an issue that seemed too big for you to tackle? How many times have you said to yourself, “I am only one person, what can I do?”
How many times have you remained silent when you felt compelled to speak?
Much to her credit, Chloe did not stand idly by. She took action. By doing so, Chloe proved to the world that one single voice can make a huge difference. Not only did her headmaster listen, he responded with compassion and concern for Chloe as well as her fellow students.
Chloe’s headmaster response shows that when openly communicated with, there are people who listen and respond appropriately.
This story proves the only voice not heard is the one that is silent.]
Chloe’s letter to her Headmaster
17/09/19
To Mr. *********
My name is Chloe & I’m one of your Year 11 students.
My reason for this email is to tell you that I’ve been extremely upset & feel very hurt that my feelings haven’t been considered regarding having the extremely large promoting HPV vaccine poster up in school. As far as I’m aware everyone in school as in teaching staff & my group of friends know what caused me to become ill.
I first saw this poster on Friday & it has been on my mind ever since, I told my parents that I was going to ask who was responsible for advertising within the school & how it had upset me. I felt I needed to deal with this situation myself & not just getting them to call the school.
So, I went to pastoral this afternoon, as I wasn’t in this morning as didn’t feel great Sunday afternoon or yesterday at school & hadn’t slept so I came in at break. Mr. ******** saw me in there he came & looked at the poster & said he would talk to you & the caretakers about it. So, I’ve taken it upon myself to email you.
You probably don’t know me or my background but since having the HPV vaccine in July 2017 (when I was in Year 8) I became unwell straight after that vaccine. When I walked in that room to have it, that was the last time I felt 100% well.
I kept fainting & feeling constantly dizzy, mum phoned the Doctors to ask if it was a side-effect the following day & was told no by the receptionist.
I got worse so went to the Doctors, said my blood pressure was very low but my heart rate was fast & instead of doing a blood test as I hate needles to leave it a few weeks once the vaccine was out of body & hopefully, I would feel better.
This didn’t happen. I just got worse.
Had blood tests & hospital appointments, but still I got worse. I remember my Dad asking the cardiologist at the hospital if I could possibly have POTS as they had been looking into my symptoms & found many girls suffered the same as me after the vaccine & had reached out to others.
She basically laughed saying no & to go back in 4 months if no improvement but to drink at least 3 liters of water & 10g of salt (this is what people with POTS are told to do.)
I was so upset as she didn’t help, it wasn’t long after my mum took me back to the see a Doctor as I was getting worse still. He was the best I had seen since our family GP had retired & agreed it was possible that all my symptoms were pointing to POTS so said he would start treating me instead of waiting for tests as I would have to suffer longer & hopefully, I would improve.
I will never forget my Dad talking to the cardiologist after she returned his call when he said he wasn’t happy & that she was lucky he wasn’t putting in a formal complaint about the way she treated us. She said what the GP gave me is what she would have given me if I had gone back in 4 months to see her.
She kept saying sorry to my Dad & asked how he knew so much. He told her had you had a fit & healthy child then they had a vaccine & suddenly became ill straight after & no Doctors are really helping or giving answers wouldn’t u look for answers yourself (I remember my mum looking online while sitting up with me during the nights when I would sit there & cry when I felt so ill & had enough)
When Dad asked her if my symptoms were linked to the HPV vaccine, she said it’s thought to be linked but she can’t comment & wouldn’t put it in writing.
What hope do people like me have when even Doctors treat us like this???
I lost my last two summer holidays as I was in bed. Before this I was a very active person, I love to dance, do sport & generally be active. But I had to stop dancing which I was really good at & loved doing, I could no longer go to the Gym 2/3 times a week & I loved doing PE but now I have to just sit & watch as my friends all get to do it.
A list of my symptoms (when it started)
Constantly dizzy (having to hold myself up on furniture as couldn’t stand up)
Fainting (would lose count this happened lots but I learnt when it was going to happen & sit down)
Heart palpitations (swear my heart was coming out of my chest & would hurt)
Headaches all the time
Feeling sick all the time
Tremors in my legs & arms (remember one of the office ladies thought I was cold but it was my tremors)
Sharp shooting pain & pins & needles
Chronic fatigue (literally couldn’t stay awake at my worst point or hold my own head up off the pillow)
Insomnia
My whole body ached & hurt
Heat intolerance (I can’t cope with temperature change when I get hot I instantly feel rough & it knocks me back, can take days to get back on track)
Hot flushes
Extreme sweating
Hair loss
Lack of energy
Exercise intolerant
Pale in the face (unable to get a tan at all now)
Low blood pressure
Lack of memory
Poor concentration
Brain Fog
No awareness of what’s going on around me, like I go off in my own world
Unable to stand for anytime (when I’m in science doing experiments, I have to either sit down or lean on the side as it makes me feel rough)
Having to live with this is hard & I do get upset but I try not to show how upset I am & I’ve not long started seeing the school counsellor, but I haven’t seen her for a while for some reason.
I try to be in school as much as I can. I’m not one of these people that will happily miss school & finger crossed I haven’t for some time. I love being there with my group of friends & when I’m not there I feel more upset. But sometimes it’s been impossible when I’m so ill, I know mum has told school before they are more than welcome to come & see me when I’ve been off really ill.
I’ve been seeing a lady called Rita since July 2018, who specializes in girls like me, damaged from the HPV vaccine. She’s treated hundreds of us. It’s only because I was so ill my mum was searching for something that might help as she didn’t know what else to do & joined a support group & they were recommending Rita. The following day my Dad contacted her & I got a cancellation appointment.
She’s so lovely & understands how I feel & believes me.
I’m lucky my parents can afford my homeopathy appointments & treatments as some parents can’t.
There are so many other girls like me, not just in the UK but around the world. And boys also in other countries. I have to remember when I’m down that I’m lucky as I’m not as worse off as others, some paralyzed & others have died after this vaccine.
There’s a UK Association of HPV vaccine injured daughters (AHVID) they have over 640 UK families on their database, all have injured daughters this includes me.
Someone I know in another school didn’t have the HPV vaccine, because of what it did to me. A close family member of hers is a GP too.
It annoys me that my parents get called anti-vaxxers or accused of scaremongering as they aren’t, they have given me every vaccine that’s been on offer & my sisters too.
I didn’t want to have the HPV vaccine as I hate needles but my mum thought it was for the best as she had a friend with cervical cancer who’s since lost their fight & she thought I wouldn’t ever get it then, but now we know this isn’t true. There are women that have had the vaccine & got cervical cancer at a very young age, just we don’t really get told about this. My mum now gets so angry with herself that she didn’t look into this vaccine first before making me have it.
As my parents tell people they’re not telling them not to have the vaccine but to look into it first, although this is now being proved very difficult to look into as many of these sites are being shut down which is very sad, scary & frustrating to me.
The amount of times I’ve been called faking being ill or people just haven’t believed me is really hard for me to deal with. If only that was true, I would love to feel normal.
Not only do I have to live with the effects but I’m now being reminded of it when I’m in school having this poster in my face.
I cannot stress how much I really want this poster taken down, as I’ve said it’s not nice for me to see & if it’s not I can get some posters made up regarding side effects that I will quite happily print off & stick next to this poster and any others I see around school as I believe people deserve to know both sides of this vaccine. I did say to Mr. ******* if I made some of my own posters would I be allowed to put them up, but he didn’t comment.
This is something I feel very passionate about & you can’t blame me I’ve lost so much time being ill & even now “I’m ok” (when I say I’m ok I’m not, I’m just the best I have been since being injured by this vaccine & have to get on with it, as I’m sure not everyone wants to hear I’m not ok)
I spoke about this for my English language exam at the end of yr. 10 because I feel people deserve the right to know it’s not all good. I was really proud of it & would have liked you to have heard it, it contained information about the manufacturer of the drug & their previous drugs that got banded.
I’ve got my notes if you would be interested in reading it?
Sadly, we all get told it’s a coincidence that we all have pretty much the same set of symptoms after the vaccine.
I hope you can understand where I’m coming from, if not imagine if this happened to your daughter or family member. I just want you to be aware of what your allowing to be advertised in your school as I’m sure if someone was to become ill like me you would feel bad after I have informed you of what has happened to me. Not everyone puts two & two together to realize why their child is suddenly ill.
I’m sorry if you think this email is having a go or comes across harsh or rude to you because that is not my intention, I’m just trying to get my point across. And I’m having to do it in an email as if I just spoke to you the likelihood of me forgetting what I want to say is very likely as my memory or lack of it is one of my symptoms I’ve been left with.
This email has taken ages from when I got in from school until late & I’ve been very emotional writing it, I’ve cried every time I’ve read back through it.
So please don’t just ignore it.
Below I’ve put some links. There’s so much more I could add but thought that was enough for now.
Anyway, thank you for reading this sorry it’s so long & if you would like to talk to me, I would be more than happy too.
~ Chloe
The Headmaster Responds
After my daughter sent her email to the headmaster, she had a meeting with him & we spoke to him over the phone.
The poster was removed, which we all feel was a massive win for her as she was really upset & felt she was having it rubbed in her face.
He told us that the poster is given to the school from the nursing team & he can categorically say the school doesn’t get paid anything to put up the poster or anything of its kind.
He has removed the poster & will not put it back up unless he is forced to do so by the powers above him, but if that was to be the case he would want answers to some of his questions that he has about it due to us bringing it to his attention as he didn’t know there were issues with it. Also, he would forward us the contact details of whoever it was that tells him to put it up so we could also take it up with them.
And if it had to go back up, he would talk to us about it first & walk around the school with Chloe to find somewhere in the school that she doesn’t go, so that she doesn’t have to see it.
He also said he didn’t feel the poster needed to be there, as the parents had already had the consent letters.
Also, if a child decided they didn’t want the vaccine even after parents have given their consent, they wouldn’t be made to have it (which is good to hear)
He was very apologetic that Chloe was upset about the poster being up & that she felt nobody considered her feelings about putting up the poster.
He said that he would have to have a talk with the team who deals with PSHCE days (personal social help and citizen education) to see if it would be possible to have a discussion about reactions to vaccines alongside the topic of climate change, etc.… that they do on these days.
But he didn’t want Chloe to feel that she was being belittled at all.
Please remember: The only voice that is not heard is the one that is silent.
Read the full article at SaneVax.org.
Comment on this article at VaccineImpact.com.
Leaving a lucrative career as a nephrologist (kidney doctor), Dr. Suzanne Humphries is now free to actually help cure people.
In this autobiography she explains why good doctors are constrained within the current corrupt medical system from practicing real, ethical medicine.
One of the sane voices when it comes to examining the science behind modern-day vaccines, no pro-vaccine extremist doctors have ever dared to debate her in public.
Book – The Vaccine Court “The Dark Truth of America’s Vaccine Injury Compensation Program” ORDER HERE!
Say NO to Mandatory Vaccines T-Shirt
100% Pre-shrunk Cotton
Order here!
Make a Statement for Health Freedom!
Big Pharma and government health authorities are trying to pass laws mandating vaccines for all children, and even adults.
Show your opposition to forced vaccinations and support the cause of Vaccine Impact, part of the Health Impact News network.
Order here!


healthimpactnews--2020-04-29--Michigan Doctor Raided by FBI and Arrested for Treating COVID19 Patients with Vitamin C

As we have previously reported here at Health Impact News , doctors all across the world have seen great success in treating COVID-19 patients with high-dose intravenous Vitamin C therapy .
When we first reported on doctors doing this in China just after the Wuhan outbreak , Facebook tagged us as “ Fake News ” and took away our ability to advertise and boost any of our articles .
See : More Vitamin C Studies Approved in China to Fight Coronavirus : Therapy Censored in U.S .
Since that time , we have reported on how many doctors and hospitals @ @ @ @ @ @ @ used the treatment .
See : New York Hospitals Treating Coronavirus Patients with Vitamin C Now , a doctor in Michigan has actually had his clinic raided by the FBI and arrested being accused of “ committing health care fraud and conspiracy to commit health care fraud ” because he treated his patients with Vitamin C. Michigan Doctor Charged with Felonies for Treating Coronavirus Patients with Vitamin C A Michigan doctor has had his Metro Detroit clinic raided following allegations that he was “ illegally ” treating coronavirus patients with Vitamin C. Dr. @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Medical Spa in Shelby Township , has been accused of committing health care fraud and conspiracy to commit health care fraud .
He is being charged in federal court for these supposed crimes .
Mok is an advocate for treating coronavirus patients with Vitamin C in order to boost their immune systems while they fight off the virus .
This has become a controversial notion , as hysteria proponents stand in the way of any treatment that does not involve forcing vaccine shots into millions of people .
Federal jackboots surrounded the Allure @ @ @ @ @ @ @ They are claiming that his treatments do not qualify for Medicare reimbursements because they have not been rubber-stamped for approval by the Medical Mafia at the FDA .
He is also being accused of conducting illegal vein treatment after all “ non-essential businesses ” were forced to close by an edict from Governor Gretchen Whitmer .
Mok announced on YouTube that “ IV vitamin C is being used in hospitals across the country to treat the most advanced disease associated with COVID-19.
” This may have prompted the feds to shut down his @ @ @ @ @

Comments by Brian Shilhavy
Editor, Health Impact News
As we have previously reported here at Health Impact News, doctors all across the world have seen great success in treating COVID-19 patients with high-dose intravenous Vitamin C therapy.
When we first reported on doctors doing this in China just after the Wuhan outbreak, Facebook tagged us as “Fake News” and took away our ability to advertise and boost any of our articles. See:
Since that time, we have reported on how many doctors and hospitals here in the U.S. have also successfully used the treatment. See:
Now, a doctor in Michigan has actually had his clinic raided by the FBI and arrested being accused of “committing health care fraud and conspiracy to commit health care fraud” because he treated his patients with Vitamin C.
Michigan Doctor Charged with Felonies for Treating Coronavirus Patients with Vitamin C
by Shane Trejo
Big League Politics
Excerpts:
A Michigan doctor has had his Metro Detroit clinic raided following allegations that he was “illegally” treating coronavirus patients with Vitamin C.
Dr. Charles Mok, who leads the Allure Medical Spa in Shelby Township, has been accused of committing health care fraud and conspiracy to commit health care fraud. He is being charged in federal court for these supposed crimes.
Mok is an advocate for treating coronavirus patients with Vitamin C in order to boost their immune systems while they fight off the virus. This has become a controversial notion, as hysteria proponents stand in the way of any treatment that does not involve forcing vaccine shots into millions of people.
Federal jackboots surrounded the Allure facility and raided it last week. They are claiming that his treatments do not qualify for Medicare reimbursements because they have not been rubber-stamped for approval by the Medical Mafia at the FDA. He is also being accused of conducting illegal vein treatment after all “non-essential businesses” were forced to close by an edict from Governor Gretchen Whitmer.
Mok announced on YouTube that “IV vitamin C is being used in hospitals across the country to treat the most advanced disease associated with COVID-19.” This may have prompted the feds to shut down his operation by brute force.
Read the Full Article at Big League Politics


healthimpactnews--2020-04-29--Crisis in America: Hospitals Across the Country Begin to Close due to Lack of Patients – Nurses and

Crisis in America: Hospitals Across the Country Begin to Close due to Lack of Patients – Nurses and Doctors being Laid Off

The so-called Coronavirus pandemic “ crisis ” is very quickly taking a back seat to more serious crises in the U.S. right now , and perhaps none more critical than the closure of hospitals and emergency rooms , along with doctors and nurses being laid off , which is happening all across the country .
During the early stages of the Coronavirus outbreak , the corporate-sponsored “ mainstream ” media flooded the airways with images of over-crowded hospitals , supposed corpses being carried out in body bags , and other gruesome details that brought fear to the public .
Soon @ @ @ @ @ @ @ began going to these hospitals to see first hand these horrible images , and they began to film and share on social media what they were seeing : hospitals and emergency rooms either empty or less crowded than usual .
Fast forward to today , at the end of April , and now not even the corporate media can deny that hospitals are suffering due to a lack of patients , as most states have shut down “ non-essential ” medical services to concentrate on treating COVID-19 patients .
Add to that the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ treatments , hospitals are obviously going to concentrate on COVID-19 treatments first , and as we have previously reported , many medical personnel are now coming forward to expose how pretty much every patient coming through the doors of hospitals are assumed to be COVID-19 patients whether they are tested or not .
As a result , whether intended or not , many hospitals are suffering financially , facing closure , and beginning to lay off their medical staffs , because other than perhaps New York City , there just are not enough @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Therefore , if you are suffering from something other than COVID-19 that needs emergency room or hospital services , such as cancer , hypertension , or any other non-respiratory illness , you risk not being able to get treatment .
So what can you do ?
You have to pretty much lie and tell the doctors or nurses that you suspect you might be infected with COVID-19 .
That gives you a free ticket , all expenses paid , access to hospital services .
Welcome to the new government-run healthcare system .
What @ @ @ @ @ @ @ years with his “ Obamacare ” to have government take over healthcare , and was only partially successful , has now happened almost overnight because of the fear driven by the Coronavirus “ pandemic.
” Here is a sample of what the corporate media is reporting regarding the crisis now facing American hospitals .
Some expectant mothers in Charlotte are losing doctors weeks before due dates How are health care workers losing their jobs during a pandemic ?
Laid Off Healthcare Worker On Going From ‘ Hero ’ To ‘ Unconsidered ’

by Brian Shilhavy
Editor, Health Impact News
The so-called Coronavirus pandemic “crisis” is very quickly taking a back seat to more serious crises in the U.S. right now, and perhaps none more critical than the closure of hospitals and emergency rooms, along with doctors and nurses being laid off, which is happening all across the country.
During the early stages of the Coronavirus outbreak, the corporate-sponsored “mainstream” media flooded the airways with images of over-crowded hospitals, supposed corpses being carried out in body bags, and other gruesome details that brought fear to the public.
Soon, however, citizens around the country began going to these hospitals to see first hand these horrible images, and they began to film and share on social media what they were seeing: hospitals and emergency rooms either empty or less crowded than usual.
Fast forward to today, at the end of April, and now not even the corporate media can deny that hospitals are suffering due to a lack of patients, as most states have shut down “non-essential” medical services to concentrate on treating COVID-19 patients.
Add to that the federal stimulus funds being directed to COVID-19 treatments, hospitals are obviously going to concentrate on COVID-19 treatments first, and as we have previously reported, many medical personnel are now coming forward to expose how pretty much every patient coming through the doors of hospitals are assumed to be COVID-19 patients whether they are tested or not.
As a result, whether intended or not, many hospitals are suffering financially, facing closure, and beginning to lay off their medical staffs, because other than perhaps New York City, there just are not enough COVID-19 patients to keep everyone employed.
Therefore, if you are suffering from something other than COVID-19 that needs emergency room or hospital services, such as cancer, hypertension, or any other non-respiratory illness, you risk not being able to get treatment.
So what can you do? You have to pretty much lie and tell the doctors or nurses that you suspect you might be infected with COVID-19. That gives you a free ticket, all expenses paid, access to hospital services.
Welcome to the new government-run healthcare system. What President Obama tried to do for 8 years with his “Obamacare” to have government take over healthcare, and was only partially successful, has now happened almost overnight because of the fear driven by the Coronavirus “pandemic.”
Here is a sample of what the corporate media is reporting regarding the crisis now facing American hospitals.
Beaumont Health in Michigan lays off 2,475 workers, permanently cutting 450 jobs
It seems counter intuitive that this could happen… What has transpired here is that the regular business of running a hospital has changed dramatically…
Some expectant mothers in Charlotte are losing doctors weeks before due dates
As WCNC first reported Friday night, HMG opted to dismiss several doctors who resigned in March but had planned to honor scheduled patient visits and contracts through September. In the days since, we learned 35 doctors, in all, lost their jobs, HMG closed 10 office locations and laid off support staff, blaming COVID-19 for a “dramatic reduction” in-office visits.
Maine hospitals losing $250 million per month during coronavirus, COVID-19 pandemic
How are health care workers losing their jobs during a pandemic?
The Oregon Clinic laid off 820 workers in the Portland area. Here’s an explanation why nurses, nurse practitioners and physicians’ assistants are losing work.
Health care workers face benefit and pay cuts amid coronavirus outbreak
The financial fallout from the pandemic is affecting health care workers in America. ER doctors are taking a 40% pay cut and getting their benefits cut during the coronavirus outbreak. Nikki Battiste reports.
North County health care workers protest temporary layoffs
Laid Off Healthcare Worker On Going From ‘Hero’ To ‘Unconsidered’


healthimpactnews--2020-04-30--Funeral Directors in COVID-19 Epicenter Doubt Legitimacy of Deaths Attributed to Pandemic

Project Veritas today released another video featuring conversations with funeral home directors and their staff throughout New York City questioning the number of deaths officially attributed to the COVID-19 pandemic .
• Judge Calls Bullsh*t on Relative ’ s COVID-19 Cause of Death • Funeral Home : To Me all You ’ re Doing is Padding the Statistics…Making the Death Rates in New York City Higher than Estimated • Brooklyn Funeral Director : They Are Padding Numbers ; Medical Examiners Too Busy to Investigate • Brooklyn Funeral Director : 40-year-old Died in Home with No Symptoms Other Than Fever , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ , a Project Veritas reporter spoke with Michael Lanza , the director of Staten Island ’ s Colonial Funeral Home .
Lanza said DeBlasio might see inflated COVID death tallies as a way to bring more money to New York City .
“ Whether they had a positive test or didn ’ t , so I think again this is my personal opinion , I think like the mayor and our city–they ’ re looking for federal funding and the more they put COVID on the death certificate the more they can ask @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Island funeral director said it did not add up to him .
“ I think it ’ s political , so , I ’ m going to turn around and say : ‘ You know , like , not everybody that we have here that has COVID on the death certificate died of COVID.
’ Can I prove that ?
No , but that is my suspicion.
” Josephine DiMiceli , president of the DiMiceli and Sons , a Queens-based funeral service told a Project Veritas journalist that a Supreme Court justice got @ @ @ @ @ @ @ death that was listed as a casualty of the pandemic .
The sister of a deceased woman called DiMiceli and told her late sister suffered with Alzheimer ’ s Disease and was not treated for COVID-19 , she said .
“ The sister refused to believe that her sister had COVID-19 and like I said , she was the one that said to me she says well my cousin is you know , Chief Justice of the Supreme Court , ” DiMiceli said .
“ We ’ re gon na get an autopsy @ @ @ @ @ @ @ you got ta do , you know and she did what she had to do and sure enough I called her and I said to her that the doctor signed the death certificate did the autopsy – no COVID-19 .
”

by Project Veritas
Excerpts:
Project Veritas today released another video featuring conversations with funeral home directors and their staff throughout New York City questioning the number of deaths officially attributed to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Judge Calls Bullsh*t on Relative’s COVID-19 Cause of Death
Funeral Home: To Me all You’re Doing is Padding the Statistics…Making the Death Rates in New York City Higher than Estimated
Staten Island Funeral Director Questions Mayor DeBlasio’s Role and Adds: I Think It’s Political
Brooklyn Funeral Director: They Are Padding Numbers; Medical Examiners Too Busy to Investigate
Brooklyn Funeral Director: 40-year-old Died in Home with No Symptoms Other Than Fever, Toe-Tagged as COVID-19 Victim
In late April, a Project Veritas reporter spoke with Michael Lanza, the director of Staten Island’s Colonial Funeral Home.
“To be honest with you, all of the death certificates are writing COVID on it, they’re writing
COVID on all the death certificates,” Lanza said.
Lanza said DeBlasio might see inflated COVID death tallies as a way to bring more money to New York City.
“Whether they had a positive test or didn’t, so I think again this is my personal opinion, I think like the mayor and our city–they’re looking for federal funding and the more they put COVID on the death certificate the more they can ask from the federal funds.”
The Staten Island funeral director said it did not add up to him.
“I think it’s political, so, I’m going to turn around and say: ‘You know, like, not everybody that we have here that has COVID on the death certificate died of COVID.’ Can I prove that? No, but that is my suspicion.”
Josephine DiMiceli, president of the DiMiceli and Sons, a Queens-based funeral service told a Project Veritas journalist that a Supreme Court justice got involved in one case of a non-COVID-19 death that was listed as a casualty of the pandemic.
The sister of a deceased woman called DiMiceli and told her late sister suffered with Alzheimer’s Disease and was not treated for COVID-19, she said.
“The sister refused to believe that her sister had COVID-19 and like I said, she was the one that said to me she says well my cousin is you know, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court,” DiMiceli said. “We’re gonna get an autopsy,’ and I said do what you gotta do, you know and she did what she had to do and sure enough I called her and I said to her that the doctor signed the death certificate did the autopsy – no COVID-19.”
Read the Full Article Here.
Watch the full report:


healthimpactnews--2020-04-30--The War on Cash: Using COVID-19 to Make Sure the Rich Get Richer and Control the Monetary System?

There has been much written lately about how the COVID-19 “ pandemic ” is being used as an excuse to usher in some kind of national “ Medical ID ” that could be used as a tool to control our daily activities , and be used as a requirement to do almost everything in society , from buying goods to travel to receiving medical treatment and beyond .
Such concerns are certainly legitimate given what we have seen so far in the “ war against the invisible enemy ” and the government ’ s reaction to this “ war.
” @ @ @ @ @ @ @ responses who would love to track and control most aspects of your personal life are not simply restricted to a medical ID card .
I was recently in a store purchasing some grocery products , and the sign at the checkout said : “ Due to the Coronavirus situation we are no longer accepting cash.
” This may seen like a minor inconvenience to most people , but Attorney James Rickards , an American lawyer , economist , and investment banker with 35 years of experience working in capital markets on Wall Street @ @ @ @ @ @ @ War on Cash ” for years now .
When the flow of cash is limited to digital money and the approval of banks , near total control of the population is much more easily accomplished .
I ’ ve been warning investors for months about the war on cash .
This war has been in full swing in Europe and the U.S. for a long time .
Governments plan to use negative interest rates , confiscatory taxes and other techniques to rob savers of their wealth .
In order to do this , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ accounts at large government-controlled banks .
As long as savers can hold cash , they can avoid many of these confiscation techniques .
Therefore , governments must eliminate cash .
The latest battleground in this war is India .
In a shock announcement on Nov. 8 , India declared that 500- and 1,000-rupee notes are no longer legal tender .
Imagine that — the money in your wallet or purse is instantly made worthless by government decree .
That ’ s what happened .
There were limited exceptions for hospitals and gas stations @ @ @ @ @ @ @ , and some people rushed to hospitals to prepay for future medical care with now worthless bank notes .
The other exception to worthlessness was if you deposited the notes in the bank .
There you would receive “ digital credit ” in your account .
Of course , the tax man was waiting at the bank to ask you where you got the money .
Those without an acceptable answer can expect trouble from the Indian Revenue Service .
this is not the end of the war on cash .
It ’ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ the Full Article Here . )
That was 2016 .
Today , at the end of April , 2020 , he updated his predictions based on the COVID-19 pandemic and the actions currently being taken .
In the depths of the 2008–09 financial crisis , Obama ’ s first chief of staff , Rahm Emanuel , remarked that one should never let a good crisis go to waste .
You probably recall him saying that .
He was referring to the fact that crises may be temporary but hidden agendas are permanent .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ always have a laundry list of programs and regulations they can ’ t wait to put into practice .
They know that most of these are deeply unpopular and they could never get away with putting them into practice during ordinary times .
Yet when a crisis hits , citizens are desperate for fast action and quick solutions .
The elites bring forward their rescue packages but then use these as Trojan horses to sneak their wish list inside .
The War on Cash Is Decades Old The USA Patriot Act that passed @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Some counterterrorist measures were needed , of course .
But the Treasury had a long-standing wish list involving reporting cash transactions and limiting citizens ’ ability to get cash .
They plugged that wish list into the Patriot Act and we ’ ve been living with the results ever since , even though 9/11 is long in the past .
Obviously , the effort to eliminate cash is hardly new .
It has been going on for many years and in many forms .
The U.S. discontinued the use of large-denomination bills in @ @ @ @ @ @ @ $ 500 , $ 1,000 , $ 5,000 and even $ 10,000 bills were issued , even though they were printed decades earlier .
Today the largest bill is a $ 100 bill , but it has lost 80 % of its purchasing power since 1968 , so it ’ s really just a $ 20 bill from those days .
Europe has ended the 500-euro note and today the largest note in euros is 200 euros .
Harvard professor Ken Rogoff has a book called The Curse of Cash , which calls @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Many Bitcoin groupies say the same thing .
Central banks and the IMF are all working on new digital currencies today .
The reasons for this are said to include attacks on tax evasion , terrorism and criminal activity .
There ’ s some truth to these claims .
Cash is anonymous , so it can ’ t be tracked .
But the real reason is because the elimination of cash would allow elites to impose negative interest rates , account freezes and confiscation .
They can ’ t do that as long @ @ @ @ @ @ @ and withdraw your cash .
That ’ s the key .
In other words , it ’ s much easier for them to control your money if they first herd you into a digital cattle pen .
That ’ s their true objective and all the other reasons are just a smokescreen .
And now , predictably , the latest attack on cash comes courtesy of the COVID-19 pandemic .
( Read the Full Article Here . )

Comments by Brian Shilhavy
Editor, Health Impact News
There has been much written lately about how the COVID-19 “pandemic” is being used as an excuse to usher in some kind of national “Medical ID” that could be used as a tool to control our daily activities, and be used as a requirement to do almost everything in society, from buying goods to travel to receiving medical treatment and beyond.
Such concerns are certainly legitimate given what we have seen so far in the “war against the invisible enemy” and the government’s reaction to this “war.”
But opportunists taking advantage of the COVID-19 responses who would love to track and control most aspects of your personal life are not simply restricted to a medical ID card.
I was recently in a store purchasing some grocery products, and the sign at the checkout said: “Due to the Coronavirus situation we are no longer accepting cash.”
This may seen like a minor inconvenience to most people, but Attorney James Rickards, an American lawyer, economist, and investment banker with 35 years of experience working in capital markets on Wall Street, has been warning about the “War on Cash” for years now. When the flow of cash is limited to digital money and the approval of banks, near total control of the population is much more easily accomplished.
Back in 2016 he wrote:
I’ve been warning investors for months about the war on cash. This war has been in full swing in Europe and the U.S. for a long time. Governments plan to use negative interest rates, confiscatory taxes and other techniques to rob savers of their wealth. In order to do this, they have to force savings into digital accounts at large government-controlled banks. As long as savers can hold cash, they can avoid many of these confiscation techniques. Therefore, governments must eliminate cash. The latest battleground in this war is India. In a shock announcement on Nov. 8, India declared that 500- and 1,000-rupee notes are no longer legal tender. Imagine that — the money in your wallet or purse is instantly made worthless by government decree. That’s what happened. There were limited exceptions for hospitals and gas stations. Naturally, gas lines formed everywhere, and some people rushed to hospitals to prepay for future medical care with now worthless bank notes. The other exception to worthlessness was if you deposited the notes in the bank. There you would receive “digital credit” in your account. Of course, the tax man was waiting at the bank to ask you where you got the money. Those without an acceptable answer can expect trouble from the Indian Revenue Service. this is not the end of the war on cash. It’s just the beginning. (Read the Full Article Here.)
That was 2016. Today, at the end of April, 2020, he updated his predictions based on the COVID-19 pandemic and the actions currently being taken.


healthimpactnews--2020-04-30--Do We Actually Have a Test that Can Accurately Identify a COVID-19 Virus?

Tests that can accurately test for the COVID-19 virus have been a hot topic since the pandemic started .
I have previously highlighted the pharmaceutical infighting with each other over the lucrative COVID-19 test market , where it is admitted that some tests , in this case anti-body testings , are notoriously unreliable .
See : Roche CEO : COVID19 Tests “ Not Worth Anything – Two of us could do it Overnight in the Garage ” This begs the question : do we actually have a test that can accurately identify a COVID-19 virus ?
It is a controversial @ @ @ @ @ @ @ of COVID-19 deaths are broadcast daily , like the score of a sports game , and uniformly accepted as accurate , never questioning the accuracy of these numbers .
If the question does come up in the corporate media , the general assumption is that the true numbers are probably much higher .
Mary Holland , former Professor of Law at NYU and current General Counsel for the Children ’ s Health Defense , just published an article : Coronavirus and Infection Control : What ’ s Going on with Testing ?
She @ @ @ @ @ @ @ a pathologist and research scientist based in Connecticut who has been producing molecular tests for diseases and conditions for many years , including Lyme disease and human papilloma virus ( HPV ) infection .
Dr. Lee trained and taught in some of the world ’ s most prestigious institutions and has published scores of scientific articles in peer-reviewed journals .
Dr. Lee is a hero to those concerned about HPV vaccine safety because he proved that the HPV vaccine contained HPV DNA fragments , something that Merck and the Food and Drug Administration @ @ @ @ @ @ @ were part of the reasons for so many adverse events .
His research made the FDA come clean about the presence of the DNA in the vaccine , but the agency continued to deny its significance and harmful potential .
The need for accurate coronavirus testing is imperative .
It is especially critical in nursing homes and institutions caring for elderly patients , so that false-positive patients are not housed with true-positive patients .
It ’ s also essential to ensure that staff in direct contact with highly susceptible patients be infection-free .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ overcome the roadblocks in coronavirus testing – only to hit new ones at the very agencies responsible for ensuring the pandemic ’ s end .
Dr. Lee wrote to the WHO and to Dr. Anthony Fauci at the National Institute of Allergies and Infectious Diseases of the National Institutes of Health ( NIH ) to explain why the current tests to detect SARS-CoV-2 RNA are generating false positives and negatives .
He explained that a two-phased test would “ guarantee no-false positive results ” based on his research and published work from Japan @ @ @ @ @ @ @ of any patient samples that have generated questionable results , using a highly sensitive nested reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction ( PCR ) test followed by DNA sequencing of a unique 398 bp N gene amplicon for confirmation .
Dr. Lee asked to be in contact with the coronavirus teams at the WHO and NIH so that he could assist them to ensure highly accurate tests , especially for elder care facilities where the need is greatest for extreme accuracy .
Given the specificity of his letter , with its charts on DNA @ @ @ @ @ @ @ disease spread , it is almost unbelievable that as of April 27 , Dr. Lee has received no response from either the WHO or NIH .
He has similarly reached out to the Connecticut Department of Public Health to receive patient samples for further validation testing .
The Connecticut Department has stopped responding to Dr. Lee ’ s emails and phone calls .
Please read Dr. Lee ’ s March 22 letter and decide for yourself if these agencies are serving the public interest or if perhaps they are serving competing or corrupt @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Article here . )
Investigative reporter Jon Rappoport , a veteran journalist with over 38 years of experience , has also addressed the issue of accurate testing .
Rappoport makes no apologies for claiming that the COVID-19 virus may not even exist , and he has very compelling evidence to back up his claim .
If you have not yet listened to his 3-part podcast on this subject , it is well worth your time .
Even if you do not agree with his conclusions , you may learn some new facts you @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Independent Journalist of 38 Years Questions Official Narrative of COVID19 – Warns of U.S .
Becoming a Medical Police State Regarding testing for a COVID-19 virus , he echoes much of what Dr .
Sin Hang Lee is questioning : The claim of having discovered a new virus ( COVID-19 ) is wrong ( unproven ) .
And the claim that the main diagnostic test ( the PCR ) can determine whether a person is sick or is going to get sick is also wrong ( unproven ) .
What seems to be @ @ @ @ @ @ @ in the real world .
The first experiment would confirm or deny the accuracy of the PCR diagnostic test .
The experiment would reveal whether this widespread test for COVID-19 can actually predict illness in the real world , in humans , not in the lab .
This experiment has never been done .
It should have been done before the PCR was ever permitted to make claims about THE QUANTIY OF VIRUS that is replicating in a patient ’ s body .
Quantity is vital , because , in order to even @ @ @ @ @ @ @ cause disease , millions and millions of virus must be actively replicating in a patient ’ s body .
Here is the experiment .
Assemble a group of 500 volunteers , some sick , some healthy .
Take tissue samples from them , and give the samples to PCR technicians .
The technicians will never see or know who the 500 volunteers are .
The techs run these samples through the PCR .
For each sample , they report which virus they found , and how much of it they found .
“ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ , 165 , and 433 , we found a great deal of the following disease-causing viruses.
” Now we un-blind those specific patients .
By the test results , they should all be sick .
Are they ?
Aren ’ t they ?
Then we would know .
We would know how accurate and relevant the test is in the real world .
Of course , this is not the end of the experiment .
The same samples should have been given to a whole other set of PCR techs to run .
@ @ @ @ @ @ @ results the first set of PR techs did ?
Several new groups of 500 patients each should be enlisted , and still more sets of lab techs should repeat the experiment , ending up with confirmation or rejection of the initial findings .
This is the way the scientific method is supposed to work .
In the absence of this experiment , the quantitative PCR must be looked at as a rogue hypothesis that should never have been foisted on the public in the first place .
It should never be used as @ @ @ @ @ @ @ any disease .
In the “ COVID-19 crisis , ” all case numbers derived from the PCR should be thrown out .
The second vital experiment concerns the discovery of a new virus—in this case , COVID-19 .
First of all , there is no lab procedure that can climb inside the human body in real time and record the active replication of millions of virus .
The closest you can come involves the use of electron microscopy .
Suspecting the existence of a new disease-causing virus , researchers should line up , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ people who seem to have the new disease .
Tissue samples should be taken from them .
Using correct steps of isolating-purifying-centrifuging these samples , specimens of the results should be examined and photographed under the electron microscope .
In every one of the several hundred photos , do the researchers see many identical particles of a virus they ’ ve never seen before ; and do the researchers see that these many particles are the same from photo to photo ?
If so , and if more than one group of researchers @ @ @ @ @ @ @ patients ’ tissue samples achieves the same result…then , this is as close as you can come to saying you ’ ve discovered a new disease-causing virus .
Other researchers with other large groups of patients should attempt to replicate the above findings .
This vital experiment has never been done in the case of COVID-19 .
Not even close .
Therefore , researchers can ’ t make a true claim to have discovered a new disease-causing virus .
In the absence of the two vital experiments I ’ ve described in this @ @ @ @ @ @ @ with , concerning a single “ COVID-19 ” pandemic and a single new cause , are : anecdote , rumor , gossip , conjecture , speculation , bad science , and lies .
Plus the horrendous damage from all the consequences of lockdowns based on those lies .
( Read the Full Article Here . )
Comment on this article at VaccineImpact.com .
Leaving a lucrative career as a nephrologist ( kidney doctor ) , Dr. Suzanne Humphries is now free to actually help cure people .
In this autobiography she explains why @ @ @ @ @ @ @ corrupt medical system from practicing real , ethical medicine .
One of the sane voices when it comes to examining the science behind modern-day vaccines , no pro-vaccine extremist doctors have ever dared to debate her in public .
Say NO to Mandatory Vaccines T-Shirt Big Pharma and government health authorities are trying to pass laws mandating vaccines for all children , and even adults .
Show your opposition to forced vaccinations and support the cause of Vaccine Impact , part of the Health Impact News network .

Comments by Brian Shilhavy
Editor, Health Impact News
Tests that can accurately test for the COVID-19 virus have been a hot topic since the pandemic started.
I have previously highlighted the pharmaceutical infighting with each other over the lucrative COVID-19 test market, where it is admitted that some tests, in this case anti-body testings, are notoriously unreliable. See:
This begs the question: do we actually have a test that can accurately identify a COVID-19 virus?
It is a controversial question, and yet the official numbers of COVID-19 deaths are broadcast daily, like the score of a sports game, and uniformly accepted as accurate, never questioning the accuracy of these numbers.
If the question does come up in the corporate media, the general assumption is that the true numbers are probably much higher.
Where’s the proof?
Mary Holland, former Professor of Law at NYU and current General Counsel for the Children’s Health Defense, just published an article:
She quotes Dr. Sin Hang Lee, a pathologist and research scientist based in Connecticut who has been producing molecular tests for diseases and conditions for many years, including Lyme disease and human papilloma virus (HPV) infection. Dr. Lee trained and taught in some of the world’s most prestigious institutions and has published scores of scientific articles in peer-reviewed journals.
She writes:
Dr. Lee is a hero to those concerned about HPV vaccine safety because he proved that the HPV vaccine contained HPV DNA fragments, something that Merck and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) denied. These fragments were part of the reasons for so many adverse events. His research made the FDA come clean about the presence of the DNA in the vaccine, but the agency continued to deny its significance and harmful potential. The need for accurate coronavirus testing is imperative. It is especially critical in nursing homes and institutions caring for elderly patients, so that false-positive patients are not housed with true-positive patients. It’s also essential to ensure that staff in direct contact with highly susceptible patients be infection-free. Dr. Lee has been working diligently to overcome the roadblocks in coronavirus testing – only to hit new ones at the very agencies responsible for ensuring the pandemic’s end. Dr. Lee wrote to the WHO and to Dr. Anthony Fauci at the National Institute of Allergies and Infectious Diseases of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to explain why the current tests to detect SARS-CoV-2 RNA are generating false positives and negatives. He explained that a two-phased test would “guarantee no-false positive results” based on his research and published work from Japan. He offered to retest the residues of any patient samples that have generated questionable results, using a highly sensitive nested reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test followed by DNA sequencing of a unique 398 bp N gene amplicon for confirmation. Dr. Lee asked to be in contact with the coronavirus teams at the WHO and NIH so that he could assist them to ensure highly accurate tests, especially for elder care facilities where the need is greatest for extreme accuracy. Given the specificity of his letter, with its charts on DNA sequencing, and its significance for preventing disease spread, it is almost unbelievable that as of April 27, Dr. Lee has received no response from either the WHO or NIH. He has similarly reached out to the Connecticut Department of Public Health to receive patient samples for further validation testing. The Connecticut Department has stopped responding to Dr. Lee’s emails and phone calls. Please read Dr. Lee’s March 22 letter and decide for yourself if these agencies are serving the public interest or if perhaps they are serving competing or corrupt interests instead. (Read the Full Article here.)
Investigative reporter Jon Rappoport, a veteran journalist with over 38 years of experience, has also addressed the issue of accurate testing.
Rappoport makes no apologies for claiming that the COVID-19 virus may not even exist, and he has very compelling evidence to back up his claim. If you have not yet listened to his 3-part podcast on this subject, it is well worth your time. Even if you do not agree with his conclusions, you may learn some new facts you did not previously know. See:
Regarding testing for a COVID-19 virus, he echoes much of what Dr. Sin Hang Lee is questioning:
The claim of having discovered a new virus (COVID-19) is wrong (unproven). And the claim that the main diagnostic test (the PCR) can determine whether a person is sick or is going to get sick is also wrong (unproven). What seems to be true in the lab is not sufficient in the real world. The first experiment would confirm or deny the accuracy of the PCR diagnostic test. The experiment would reveal whether this widespread test for COVID-19 can actually predict illness in the real world, in humans, not in the lab. This experiment has never been done. It should have been done before the PCR was ever permitted to make claims about THE QUANTIY OF VIRUS that is replicating in a patient’s body. Quantity is vital, because, in order to even begin talking about whether a virus can cause disease, millions and millions of virus must be actively replicating in a patient’s body. Here is the experiment. Assemble a group of 500 volunteers, some sick, some healthy. Take tissue samples from them, and give the samples to PCR technicians. The technicians will never see or know who the 500 volunteers are. The techs run these samples through the PCR. For each sample, they report which virus they found, and how much of it they found. “In patients 34, 57, 83, 165, and 433, we found a great deal of the following disease-causing viruses.” Now we un-blind those specific patients. By the test results, they should all be sick. Are they? Aren’t they? Then we would know. We would know how accurate and relevant the test is in the real world. Of course, this is not the end of the experiment. The same samples should have been given to a whole other set of PCR techs to run. Did they come up with the same results the first set of PR techs did? Several new groups of 500 patients each should be enlisted, and still more sets of lab techs should repeat the experiment, ending up with confirmation or rejection of the initial findings. This is the way the scientific method is supposed to work. In the absence of this experiment, the quantitative PCR must be looked at as a rogue hypothesis that should never have been foisted on the public in the first place. It should never be used as the basis for determining case numbers of any disease. In the “COVID-19 crisis,” all case numbers derived from the PCR should be thrown out. The second vital experiment concerns the discovery of a new virus—in this case, COVID-19. First of all, there is no lab procedure that can climb inside the human body in real time and record the active replication of millions of virus. The closest you can come involves the use of electron microscopy. Suspecting the existence of a new disease-causing virus, researchers should line up, at the very least, several hundred people who seem to have the new disease. Tissue samples should be taken from them. Using correct steps of isolating-purifying-centrifuging these samples, specimens of the results should be examined and photographed under the electron microscope. In every one of the several hundred photos, do the researchers see many identical particles of a virus they’ve never seen before; and do the researchers see that these many particles are the same from photo to photo? If so, and if more than one group of researchers independently carrying out this procedure on the patients’ tissue samples achieves the same result…then, this is as close as you can come to saying you’ve discovered a new disease-causing virus. Other researchers with other large groups of patients should attempt to replicate the above findings. This vital experiment has never been done in the case of COVID-19. Not even close. Therefore, researchers can’t make a true claim to have discovered a new disease-causing virus. In the absence of the two vital experiments I’ve described in this article, all you’re left with, concerning a single “COVID-19” pandemic and a single new cause, are: anecdote, rumor, gossip, conjecture, speculation, bad science, and lies. Plus the horrendous damage from all the consequences of lockdowns based on those lies. (Read the Full Article Here.)
Comment on this article at VaccineImpact.com.
Leaving a lucrative career as a nephrologist (kidney doctor), Dr. Suzanne Humphries is now free to actually help cure people.
In this autobiography she explains why good doctors are constrained within the current corrupt medical system from practicing real, ethical medicine.
One of the sane voices when it comes to examining the science behind modern-day vaccines, no pro-vaccine extremist doctors have ever dared to debate her in public.
Book – The Vaccine Court “The Dark Truth of America’s Vaccine Injury Compensation Program” ORDER HERE!
Say NO to Mandatory Vaccines T-Shirt
100% Pre-shrunk Cotton
Order here!
Make a Statement for Health Freedom!
Big Pharma and government health authorities are trying to pass laws mandating vaccines for all children, and even adults.
Show your opposition to forced vaccinations and support the cause of Vaccine Impact, part of the Health Impact News network.
Order here!


healthimpactnews--2020-04-30--Kentucky Parents of 7 Children Investigated for Abuse Because They did not Practice “Social Distanci

Kentucky Parents of 7 Children Investigated for Abuse Because They did not Practice “Social Distancing” at Bank Visit

Early in March , when a homeschooling family in Kentucky returned home from running errands in town , two officials—a Child Protective Services ( CPS ) investigator and a law enforcement officer—were waiting , demanding to interview their children and examine them for bruises .
Why did this happen ?
Short version : That day , mom and dad had gone to the bank with five of their children .
The bank staff criticized them for bringing so many people into the building in light of COVID-19 social distancing guidelines .
So the dad stood aside with the children while @ @ @ @ @ @ @ incident offers some important takeaways .
First , with tensions heightened and stay-at-home orders generally in place during the current health crisis , some people may be more likely to report out-and-about children as possible victims of neglect or abuse .
Second , this family ’ s experience confirms the need for CPS reform—something HSLDA has been advocating for years .
Bill and Kristy ( not their real names ) are from New York City .
They decided the kids needed a house with a backyard to play in , so they moved @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Bill could transition his work from New York .
Kristy has a Kentucky driver ’ s license , and Bill still has a New York license .
While Bill was in Kentucky on one of his frequent visits , the family ran errands , as any family in the middle of a move does .
They loaded up their seven children in the van and made their way around town , working through their errand list .
All seven children went into the various businesses with them until the family got to the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ asked to stay in the van .
A COVID-19 warning sign was posted on the bank ’ s front door .
At the desk , the teller immediately interrogated Bill and Kristy about why they had brought five kids into the bank at one time .
She told them they could not get within six feet of her and that they needed to take the children out .
Kristy explained that the children were too young to be left unsupervised by an adult , and neither she nor Bill could take them elsewhere @ @ @ @ @ @ @ account , and both had to be present .
While Bill stayed with the children away from the counter , Kristy opened the account , feeling self-conscious as the staff whispered to each other and watched her family suspiciously .
When Bill walked to the counter to show his New York ID and to sign , the bank staff asked why Bill ’ s and Kristy ’ s identifications were from different states , which the couple explained .
When they left , Kristy told Bill she would never go back into that @ @ @ @ @ @ @ people comment on her large family , but this was too much .
Then the family arrived back at their house .
A female law enforcement officer and male CPS investigator were there waiting , and immediately separated the children from Bill and Kristy .
The officials stated that they needed to do a safety check on the family ’ s “ five children ” ( not seven ) because it had been reported that the children were out in public with a strange man who was not their father , and they @ @ @ @ @ @ @ they had been improperly grabbed .
The CPS investigator moved all seven of the children farther away from Bill and Kristy and questioned the kids .
At least one of the boys had to remove his shirt , on the investigator ’ s orders .
The girls would have had to do the same , but Kristy objected and insisted on being present for the girls ’ physical examinations .
The investigator pulled up the girls ’ sleeves , lifted their clothing , and took pictures .
Kristy and Bill ’ s 10-year-old @ @ @ @ @ @ @ uncomfortable having her privacy and dignity invaded in this way .
Of course , the children did not have bruises .
And , of course , when the CPS investigator learned Bill and Kristy were homeschooling , he didn ’ t think they could adequately educate all their children .
He asked what curriculum they were using , which had nothing to do with the false allegations .
There is no question that , by this time , the investigator did know the allegations were false : not only did the children have @ @ @ @ @ @ @ not an unrelated male ( his last name on his New York driver ’ s license proved it ! )
.
The caseworker told Kristy that all her children needed physical exams , even though the report of injury was false and there were no other concerns .
Kristy explained that she had already tried to get new patient appointments , but none were available until May .
He then told her to take the kids to the health department .
She told him that she was pregnant and that taking all the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ other people could be sick with COVID-19 , didn ’ t seem like a good idea .
The investigator didn ’ t care—he said all the children “ needed to be seen.
” That ’ s when Kristy called Home School Legal Defense Association .
Our attorney , Tj Schmidt , is helping Bill and Kristy bring this wholly unnecessary investigation to a close .
For years , HSLDA has been advocating for CPS reform .
What happened to Bill and Kristy illustrates the need for two specific reforms , even if we @ @ @ @ @ @ @ number 1 : eliminate anonymous reports—Instead , require reporters to leave verifiable contact information that will remain confidential unless a report is later determined to be knowingly false or malicious .
This would significantly reduce the number of false reports—which would free up overworked CPS investigators to focus on cases where their assistance is truly needed .
CPS hotlines are too easily weaponized .
HSLDA sees this often during divorce or child custody cases or in disputes among neighbors .
We don ’ t know who made the report against Bill and Kristy @ @ @ @ @ @ @ .
And it has all the hallmarks of a weaponized false anonymous tip , made by someone who is familiar with CPS practices .
• The tip referred to five kids , and the bank was the only place where Bill and Kristy left their two older kids in the van .
• The tipster knew that the parents had driver ’ s licenses from different states , something the bank teller also knew .
• The false tip said Bill was an “ unrelated male , ” which is a known risk @ @ @ @ @ @ @ false tip also said the children had bruises on their arms that appeared to be caused by grabbing , the kind of accusation that gets a quick response .
( In fact , because it was a cool day and all the children were wearing long sleeves , whoever made the tip had not had the opportunity to see their arms at all . )
If the tipster left contact information , we intend to get it .
Most likely , the tip was made anonymously .
Reform number 2 : ban open-ended @ @ @ @ @ @ @ illustrates the need for what I call “ offramp ” legislation—that is , the requirement that caseworkers terminate an investigation immediately once they determine the allegations made in the report are false .
A hotline tip should not be an invitation to fish around for additional details about a family ’ s life .
A typical investigation includes private interviews with the children , “ body checks ” ( in other words , strip searches ) , searches of the home , medical records checks , and more .
And contrary to common @ @ @ @ @ @ @ investigators around the country that once they begin this intrusive process , they must complete it , even if they discover the tip is false .
An after-hours call I handled a few years ago aptly illustrates the point .
A homeschool mom and HSLDA member , calling from Virginia , told me that a CPS investigator was at her door demanding to come in and interview her children , based on a report that the mother frequently left her toddlers unattended by the pool in the backyard .
“ But Mr. Mason @ @ @ @ @ @ @ ’ s two things wrong with this .
First , my children are all teenagers.
” “ Well , ” she said ( more calmly than I would have ) , “ I don ’ t have a swimming pool.
” Forgetting that I was in CPS-investigator-land , I momentarily thought that common sense would prevail .
I told my caller to take the investigator to the backyard and show him that there was no swimming pool .
Then I spoke to him , certain that my unassailable logic would lead to the @ @ @ @ @ @ @ because there was nothing to see here .
“ As I am sure you will agree , ” I began , “ the anonymous report is false .
There is no swimming pool to leave anyone beside unattended , even if this mother had toddlers , which she doesn ’ t. ” As if speaking to a young child—and a none too bright one at that—the investigator explained , “ It doesn ’ t really matter that there is no pool .
I have started an investigation and I can not leave until @ @ @ @ @ @ @ to look inside the home and interview the children privately.
” It then became a whole thing .
Imagine how much more sense it would have made for the investigator to be freed up to acknowledge that the tip was false and then go about his real business—helping children who were really in danger .
HSLDA handles this kind of call way too often .
If our members involve us in the proceedings early enough , our attorneys are skilled at shepherding investigations to smooth landings , avoiding some of their more unpleasant @ @ @ @ @ @ @ One possible interpretation of what happened to Bill and Kristy—and that HSLDA will be looking into—is that a bank employee had heightened concern about COVID-19 , was offended by a large family invading her space , and made the hotline tip as a form of retaliation .
It also appears that whoever made the call knew how to juice up the details with just the right kind of false information to cause an overreaction by CPS .
In the fullness of time , we hope to get to the bottom of the situation @ @ @ @ @ @ @ happens , we will report back .
I suspect the COVID-19 crisis could lead to more panicked false reports of this kind .
While this is something to be aware of , God ’ s strong words of comfort reassure us , “ Be strong and courageous .
Do not fear or be in dread ….
” Dt 31:6a ( ESV ) .
And just as panic isn ’ t a good response to a pandemic , it ’ s not families ’ best response to the possibility of false CPS reports , @ @ @ @ @ @ @ measured , wise , and brave will get us through .
So keep calm , wash your hands , and call HSLDA .
We ’ re here no matter what .
Medical Kidnapping : A Threat to Every Family in America T-Shirt See : Medical Kidnapping : A Threat to Every Family in America Today Help spread the awareness of Medical Kidnapping by wearing the Medical Kidnapping t-shirt !
Support the cause of MedicalKidnap.com , which is part of the Health Impact News network .
Support the cause against Medical Kidnapping by purchasing @ @ @ @ @ @ @ people who are skeptical and can not believe that medical kidnapping happens in the U.S. today , this is the book for them !
Backed with solid references and real life examples , they will not be able to deny the plain evidence before them , and will become better educated on this topic that is destroying the American family .
2 Books Retail : $ 49.98 ( for 2 books ) FREE Shipping Available !
Now : $ 19.99 ( for 2 books ) Order here !

by James R. Mason, Esq.
Home School Legal Defense Association
Early in March, when a homeschooling family in Kentucky returned home from running errands in town, two officials—a Child Protective Services (CPS) investigator and a law enforcement officer—were waiting, demanding to interview their children and examine them for bruises.
Why did this happen? Short version: That day, mom and dad had gone to the bank with five of their children. The bank staff criticized them for bringing so many people into the building in light of COVID-19 social distancing guidelines. So the dad stood aside with the children while the mom transacted their business.
That’s it.
The incident offers some important takeaways. First, with tensions heightened and stay-at-home orders generally in place during the current health crisis, some people may be more likely to report out-and-about children as possible victims of neglect or abuse. Second, this family’s experience confirms the need for CPS reform—something HSLDA has been advocating for years.
Welcome to Kentucky
Bill and Kristy (not their real names) are from New York City. They decided the kids needed a house with a backyard to play in, so they moved Kristy and the kids to Kentucky before Bill could transition his work from New York. Kristy has a Kentucky driver’s license, and Bill still has a New York license.
While Bill was in Kentucky on one of his frequent visits, the family ran errands, as any family in the middle of a move does. They loaded up their seven children in the van and made their way around town, working through their errand list. All seven children went into the various businesses with them until the family got to the bank, where the oldest two children asked to stay in the van.
A COVID-19 warning sign was posted on the bank’s front door. At the desk, the teller immediately interrogated Bill and Kristy about why they had brought five kids into the bank at one time. She told them they could not get within six feet of her and that they needed to take the children out. Kristy explained that the children were too young to be left unsupervised by an adult, and neither she nor Bill could take them elsewhere because the couple were opening a joint account, and both had to be present.
While Bill stayed with the children away from the counter, Kristy opened the account, feeling self-conscious as the staff whispered to each other and watched her family suspiciously. When Bill walked to the counter to show his New York ID and to sign, the bank staff asked why Bill’s and Kristy’s identifications were from different states, which the couple explained.
When they left, Kristy told Bill she would never go back into that bank. She is used to having people comment on her large family, but this was too much.
Then the family arrived back at their house. A female law enforcement officer and male CPS investigator were there waiting, and immediately separated the children from Bill and Kristy. The officials stated that they needed to do a safety check on the family’s “five children” (not seven) because it had been reported that the children were out in public with a strange man who was not their father, and they had bruises on their arms as though they had been improperly grabbed.
The CPS investigator moved all seven of the children farther away from Bill and Kristy and questioned the kids. At least one of the boys had to remove his shirt, on the investigator’s orders. The girls would have had to do the same, but Kristy objected and insisted on being present for the girls’ physical examinations. The investigator pulled up the girls’ sleeves, lifted their clothing, and took pictures. Kristy and Bill’s 10-year-old daughter, in particular, felt extremely uncomfortable having her privacy and dignity invaded in this way.
Of course, the children did not have bruises.
False Allegations
And, of course, when the CPS investigator learned Bill and Kristy were homeschooling, he didn’t think they could adequately educate all their children. He asked what curriculum they were using, which had nothing to do with the false allegations. There is no question that, by this time, the investigator did know the allegations were false: not only did the children have no bruises, but Bill was clearly not an unrelated male (his last name on his New York driver’s license proved it!).
The caseworker told Kristy that all her children needed physical exams, even though the report of injury was false and there were no other concerns. Kristy explained that she had already tried to get new patient appointments, but none were available until May. He then told her to take the kids to the health department. She told him that she was pregnant and that taking all the kids to the health department, where other people could be sick with COVID-19, didn’t seem like a good idea.
The investigator didn’t care—he said all the children “needed to be seen.”
That’s when Kristy called Home School Legal Defense Association. Our attorney, Tj Schmidt, is helping Bill and Kristy bring this wholly unnecessary investigation to a close.
Where Pandemic Panic Meets Bad CPS Practice
For years, HSLDA has been advocating for CPS reform. What happened to Bill and Kristy illustrates the need for two specific reforms, even if we were not currently enduring COVID-19.
Reform number 1: eliminate anonymous reports—Instead, require reporters to leave verifiable contact information that will remain confidential unless a report is later determined to be knowingly false or malicious. This would significantly reduce the number of false reports—which would free up overworked CPS investigators to focus on cases where their assistance is truly needed.
CPS hotlines are too easily weaponized. HSLDA sees this often during divorce or child custody cases or in disputes among neighbors. We don’t know who made the report against Bill and Kristy, but we have a good guess. And it has all the hallmarks of a weaponized false anonymous tip, made by someone who is familiar with CPS practices.
The tip referred to five kids, and the bank was the only place where Bill and Kristy left their two older kids in the van.
The tipster knew that the parents had driver’s licenses from different states, something the bank teller also knew.
The false tip said Bill was an “unrelated male,” which is a known risk factor for child maltreatment.
The false tip also said the children had bruises on their arms that appeared to be caused by grabbing, the kind of accusation that gets a quick response. (In fact, because it was a cool day and all the children were wearing long sleeves, whoever made the tip had not had the opportunity to see their arms at all.)
If the tipster left contact information, we intend to get it. Most likely, the tip was made anonymously.
Reform number 2: ban open-ended investigations—Bill and Kristy’s experience also illustrates the need for what I call “offramp” legislation—that is, the requirement that caseworkers terminate an investigation immediately once they determine the allegations made in the report are false.
A hotline tip should not be an invitation to fish around for additional details about a family’s life. A typical investigation includes private interviews with the children, “body checks” (in other words, strip searches), searches of the home, medical records checks, and more. And contrary to common sense, it is understood by CPS investigators around the country that once they begin this intrusive process, they must complete it, even if they discover the tip is false.
Assailable Logic
An after-hours call I handled a few years ago aptly illustrates the point. A homeschool mom and HSLDA member, calling from Virginia, told me that a CPS investigator was at her door demanding to come in and interview her children, based on a report that the mother frequently left her toddlers unattended by the pool in the backyard.
“But Mr. Mason,” she said, “there’s two things wrong with this. First, my children are all teenagers.”
“What’s the second thing?” I asked.
“Well,” she said (more calmly than I would have), “I don’t have a swimming pool.”
Forgetting that I was in CPS-investigator-land, I momentarily thought that common sense would prevail. I told my caller to take the investigator to the backyard and show him that there was no swimming pool. Then I spoke to him, certain that my unassailable logic would lead to the conclusion that the investigator should move along because there was nothing to see here.
“As I am sure you will agree,” I began, “the anonymous report is false. There is no swimming pool to leave anyone beside unattended, even if this mother had toddlers, which she doesn’t.”
As if speaking to a young child—and a none too bright one at that—the investigator explained, “It doesn’t really matter that there is no pool. I have started an investigation and I cannot leave until I complete it. I still need to look inside the home and interview the children privately.”
It then became a whole thing.
Imagine how much more sense it would have made for the investigator to be freed up to acknowledge that the tip was false and then go about his real business—helping children who were really in danger.
HSLDA handles this kind of call way too often. If our members involve us in the proceedings early enough, our attorneys are skilled at shepherding investigations to smooth landings, avoiding some of their more unpleasant, intrusive, and damaging aspects.
COVID-19 Panic
One possible interpretation of what happened to Bill and Kristy—and that HSLDA will be looking into—is that a bank employee had heightened concern about COVID-19, was offended by a large family invading her space, and made the hotline tip as a form of retaliation.
It also appears that whoever made the call knew how to juice up the details with just the right kind of false information to cause an overreaction by CPS. In the fullness of time, we hope to get to the bottom of the situation and remedy this injustice. When that happens, we will report back.
I suspect the COVID-19 crisis could lead to more panicked false reports of this kind. While this is something to be aware of, God’s strong words of comfort reassure us, “Be strong and courageous. Do not fear or be in dread ….” Dt 31:6a (ESV). And just as panic isn’t a good response to a pandemic, it’s not families’ best response to the possibility of false CPS reports, either. In both cases, being measured, wise, and brave will get us through.
So keep calm, wash your hands, and call HSLDA. We’re here no matter what.
James R. Mason, Esq. Vice President of Litigation and Development
Jim is an attorney, litigator, and homeschooling dad who has helped HSLDA win a number of landmark cases establishing and protecting homeschool freedom. More stories about Medical Kidnapping in Kentucky Comment on this article at MedicalKidnap.com.
Medical Kidnapping: A Threat to Every Family in America T-Shirt
100% Pre-shrunk Cotton!
Order here!
Medical Kidnapping is REAL!
See: Medical Kidnapping: A Threat to Every Family in America Today
Help spread the awareness of Medical Kidnapping by wearing the Medical Kidnapping t-shirt!
Support the cause of MedicalKidnap.com, which is part of the Health Impact News network.
Order here!
Support the cause against Medical Kidnapping by purchasing our new book!
If you know people who are skeptical and cannot believe that medical kidnapping happens in the U.S. today, this is the book for them! Backed with solid references and real life examples, they will not be able to deny the plain evidence before them, and will become better educated on this topic that is destroying the American family.
1 Book – 228 pages
Retail: $24.99
FREE Shipping Available!
Now: $14.99
Order here!
2 Books
Retail: $49.98 (for 2 books)
FREE Shipping Available!
Now: $19.99 (for 2 books)
Order here!